Studying Time: 4 minutes
For over a decade, Wisconsin has heard the identical message from Republicans concerning full Medicaid growth: Accepting 90% federal reimbursement to cowl extra low-income folks will solely set Wisconsin up for failure if the federal authorities abandons its a part of the deal.
At first look, President Donald Trump’s not too long ago signed massive invoice seems to validate that argument. The 40 states which have totally expanded at the moment are anticipated to lose billions of {dollars} in federal help whereas getting tagged with further administrative prices to create work necessities and eligibility assessments required within the invoice.
Nevertheless it seems Wisconsin continues to be going to be topic to the brand new federal mandates with out the upper federal reimbursement charge that growth states will proceed to obtain. In different phrases, at a time when the Republican-controlled federal authorities is supposedly pulling out the rug from growth states, Wisconsin continues to be left holding the bag.
A glance again
Again in 2014, then-Gov. Scott Walker and Wisconsin Republicans made the controversial determination to not settle for full Medicaid growth.
On the time, Walker defined his objective “is to get extra folks out into the office, extra folks coated on the subject of well being care and fewer folks depending on the federal government, not as a result of we’ve kicked them out, however we’ve empowered them to take management of their very own future.”
However he additionally argued that the federal authorities would ultimately pull again on its dedication to fund Medicaid at 90%.
“That dedication isn’t going to be there and taxpayers all throughout America might be on the hook,” Walker stated. “They aren’t going to be on the hook in Wisconsin.”
On the time, Wisconsin was one among 25 states not accepting growth. Now, the state is without doubt one of the 10 remaining holdouts, with a lot of the others within the deep pink South. Even reliably pink states, like Arkansas and Louisiana, have accepted full growth.
As a substitute of accepting full growth, Wisconsin selected to cowl people by BadgerCare, the state’s Medicaid-supported medical health insurance program for low-income residents arrange by former Gov. Tommy Thompson, a Republican.
Walker and Republicans lowered Medicaid protection to 100% of the federal poverty line from the earlier 200% and eradicated the ready record for childless adults. These above the poverty line with out employer-sponsored insurance coverage may buy it by the Reasonably priced Care Act market utilizing federal subsidies, in response to the Wisconsin Coverage Discussion board.
However Wisconsin taxpayers are paying extra to cowl people under the poverty line: 39.3% of prices reasonably than 10% below full Medicaid growth. In 2023, Medicaid accounted for 15.7% of state taxpayer spending, in response to the coverage discussion board.
Below its strategy, Wisconsin doesn’t have an eligibility hole like some states, one thing Republicans spotlight as a purpose the state doesn’t must increase.
However that has include a lack of federal funds. Over the previous decade, Wisconsin’s Division of Well being Companies estimates, the state has spent about $2.6 billion extra to cowl the prices of a partial growth in contrast with the projected price below a federal growth.
Below an growth, extra people would be capable to entry Medicaid. However the Wisconsin Coverage Discussion board discovered it could have a considerably modest impression on protection ranges — the proportion change in Medicaid enrollees could be 7.2%, in contrast with practically 30% or extra in different non-expansion states.
Work necessities nonetheless in impact below Trump invoice
With the current federal invoice, Walker and different Republicans nonetheless argue Wisconsin was proper to not settle for federal growth. The state goes to expertise the impacts to a lesser extent than totally expanded states.
However as a result of Wisconsin receives federal waivers for its Medicaid program, the state continues to be topic to some provisions below the brand new regulation, together with the work necessities, eligibility determinations and supplier taxes.
Below the brand new work necessities, people coated by Medicaid are required to show they’re working 80 hours monthly — mother and father with dependent kids or people who find themselves medically frail are exempted.
Consequently, some 230,000 Wisconsin residents may lose protection whereas the state incurs administrative prices to account for the brand new necessities, in response to an estimate from U.S. Senate Democrats primarily based on information from the Congressional Finances Workplace.
The work necessities don’t cease at people coated by Medicaid alone; it additionally extends to protection by market subsidies, affecting over 200,000 Wisconsin residents.
Work necessities was once required for Wisconsin residents to entry protection by federal waivers, however in 2021 then-President Joe Biden eliminated the work requirement.
The labor pressure participation charge has dipped from about 68% in 2017 to a little bit over 65% as of Could 2025 however has remained increased than the nationwide common, which is about 62%. Some reviews counsel that decline is because of the getting older workforce within the state.
Work necessities have additionally been discovered to extend the uninsured charge.
The Wisconsin Coverage Discussion board reviews that one of many most important causes work necessities might result in increased uninsured charges is that they’re complicated and time-consuming. Some folks might select to eliminate protection altogether to keep away from pointless paperwork.
What may occur with the federal invoice?
The Kaiser Household Basis additionally discovered that implementing work necessities might be pricey for states, costing anyplace from $10 million to over $270 million, relying on the scale of the state. DHS estimates the state can pay $6 million yearly to implement work necessities, whereas receiving a decrease federal match charge than totally expanded states to reimburse for administrative prices.
With a decrease federal match charge, Wisconsin has elevated Medicaid funding by hospital taxes, which the brand new state funds simply elevated from 1.8% to the federal most of 6% for the 2025-27 biennium funds.
Republican lawmakers within the state had been fast to approve the hospital tax improve, regardless of their earlier opposition to Medicaid growth as a way for drawing down further federal funding. In the event that they hadn’t, the state’s 1.8% tax would have been frozen below Trump’s massive invoice. The rise will increase some $1 billion extra yearly in federal matching funds that the state can use to pay hospitals for care they supply Medicaid sufferers.
States that expanded is not going to lose the 90% federal match charge, however these like Wisconsin that didn’t will now miss out on an extra incentive to increase created in the course of the Biden administration.
The motivation would have raised the federal match charge to 95% for 2 years, however was eradicated by Trump’s massive invoice. As a substitute Wisconsin will stay at about 60% reimbursement, whereas nonetheless going through the identical bureaucratic necessities as growth states.
Wisconsin Watch is a nonprofit, nonpartisan newsroom. Subscribe to our newsletters for authentic tales and our Friday information roundup.
Republish our articles without spending a dime, on-line or in print, below a Artistic Commons license.
