This text is the results of a joint investigation by Bellingcat and Lloyd’s Checklist.
Ukraine has stated it’s “outraged” after a Russian-flagged vessel surreptitiously exported grain from a port underneath western sanctions in occupied Crimea to Houthi-controlled Yemen for the second time in a matter of months.
What Ukraine describes as “grain theft” through occupied ports and territories has develop into a standard prevalence for the reason that onset of Russia’s full invasion, with dozens of ships ferrying grain from occupied ports to the likes of Syria, Iran and different locations.
Ukraine has lengthy advocated for ports to reject such shipments ought to they pay attention to their origin and says it has raised the problem with the Worldwide Maritime Organisation.
On this occasion, the ship, Zafar (IMO: 9720263), loaded grain on the Port of Sevastopol in early October and arrived at Saleef (also referred to as As-Salif) in Yemen in mid-November. It docked in Djibouti within the days earlier than travelling to Saleef.
All ships bringing items into Houthi-controlled ports are mandated to cease in Djibouti for inspection by the United Nations Verification and Inspection Mechanism (UNVIM) for Yemen.
UNVIM didn’t reply to requests for remark about whether or not Zafar had been inspected whereas in Djibouti. Nor did the United Nations Workplace for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (UN OCHA), which is the UN secretariat focus for UNVIM.
Nonetheless, satellite tv for pc imagery and ship monitoring knowledge confirmed Zafar stationed at a dock in Djibouti in early November after ready in anchorage for a number of days.
Even when Zafar had been cleared by UNVIM, it couldn’t have acted simply because the true port of origin was occupied Crimea. UNVIM’s function and mandate is to facilitate the motion of economic objects to Yemeni ports not underneath the federal government’s management, whereas additionally contributing to the upholding of the UN arms embargo.
Additionally it is potential that Zafar wouldn’t have been open to UNVIM about the place it had sailed from. The truth that it masked its presence in Sevastopol by switching off its Automated Identification System (AIS), and was solely identified to have been there as a result of it was noticed in satellite tv for pc imagery, suggests it might haven’t. It will have needed to current a invoice of lading and clearance from a load port, though it isn’t potential to know what was said on these kinds with out entry to the ship’s documentation. The last word proprietor of Zafar is just not identified however the supervisor of the ship didn’t reply to requests for remark.
Such a situation would nonetheless increase questions for the UN and UNVIM.
Zafar made an an identical journey earlier this 12 months, one thing that was reported by Bellingcat and Lloyd’s Checklist on the time. Specialists informed Lloyd’s Checklist and Bellingcat again then that grain shipments from occupied Sevastopol being permitted by UNVIM, even when full particulars weren’t clear and out of doors its mandate, created an ungainly scenario for the UN given a majority of member nations have repeatedly voted towards Russia’s invasion of its neighbour.
The UN Common Meeting has handed quite a lot of resolutions towards Russia’s invasion of Crimea and japanese Ukraine relationship way back to 2014. It additionally demanded Russia withdraw all navy forces from Ukrainian territory following its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022. However in contrast to some resolutions from the Safety Council, on which Russia sits and has a veto, Common Meeting votes are not legally binding.
The Port of Sevastopol is presently underneath United States and United Kingdom sanctions, whereas the terminal that Zafar docked at in Sevastopol is underneath European Union sanctions.
Importantly, nevertheless, there are not any UN sanctions on the Port of Sevastopol or Russia.
A spokesperson for Ukraine’s Ministry of Overseas Affairs (MFA) stated that it was “outraged” that Zafar had sailed to Yemen from Crimea, though it didn’t touch upon the function of UNVIM. The spokesperson added that Ukraine “continues to make each effort to show Russia’s systematic and widespread theft of Ukrainian grain, in addition to its unlawful switch by way of Ukraine’s briefly occupied territories and illegal actions in our closed sea ports.”
Neither the Russian authorities nor its overseas ministry responded to requests for remark.
As with earlier shipments, it was additionally not clear precisely the place the grain carried by Zafar to Yemen was harvested. Nonetheless, some farmers in occupied japanese Ukraine have beforehand accused Russian forces of stealing grain that was subsequently exported.
Yemen is likely one of the world’s poorest nations. The last decade-long civil struggle between the Saudi-backed internationally recognised authorities and Iranian-backed Houthi forces has led to 1000’s of deaths and a humanitarian disaster. The UNHCR states hundreds of thousands have been displaced and there’s a danger of widespread famine.
The November grain cargo carried by Zafar arrived within the days earlier than worldwide media reported mercenaries from Yemen had been preventing on the frontline in Russia’s struggle in Ukraine.
The Monetary Occasions detailed how a whole lot of Yemenis had been being compelled to struggle for Russia, with some saying that they had been tricked into coming to Russia earlier than being taken to the entrance traces towards their will.
Whereas there isn’t a proof of any connection between the shipments and the stories of Yemenis being deployed as fighters, the Monetary Occasions reported US diplomats believed that Russia has been attempting to discover contacts with the Houthis. Nonetheless, Pentagon spokesperson Maj. Common Pat Ryder informed reporters in late November that the US had not observed any “vital” help or contributions from the Houthis to affect the struggle in Ukraine.
The US State Division didn’t deal with particular questions on Zafar when reached for remark by Bellingcat nevertheless it did specific the significance of UNVIM’s function in facilitating the motion of products whereas individually describing Russia’s theft of Ukrainian grain as “deplorable”.
How we Tracked Zafar
Zafar, a 180-metre-long bulk service, was captured on satellite tv for pc imagery loading grain on the Port of Sevastopol on October 6. It had its Automated Identification System (AIS) transponder turned off, masking its location from maritime observers and marine monitoring knowledge websites.
Intentionally switching off AIS is mostly thought of a misleading transport follow except a vessel is at risk.
Zafar had turned off its AIS on September 28, with its final recorded place simply south of the Kerch Strait between Crimea and Russia. It then visited Sevastopol the place it was pictured on satellite tv for pc imagery loading grain earlier than switching AIS again on on October 9.
The ship was pictured passing by way of the Bosphorus Strait on October 14 earlier than heading by way of the Suez Canal and onwards in the direction of Djibouti, based on AIS.
After leaving Djibouti, it sailed to Saleef in western Yemen the place satellite tv for pc imagery confirmed the ship being offloaded on November 13. AIS confirmed the ship within the port on the identical time.
After leaving Saleef on November 18, Zafar sailed again by way of the Suez Canal, Bosphorus Strait and as soon as once more into the Black Sea.
At time of writing, Zafar had anchored within the Kerch Strait, a physique of water between Russia and occupied Crimea, based on AIS knowledge.
This was the identical place it final disappeared from AIS earlier than being captured in satellite tv for pc imagery loading grain on the Port of Sevastopol.
Youri van der Weide and Eoghan Macguire contributed to this report.
Bellingcat is a non-profit and the power to hold out our work depends on the type help of particular person donors. If you want to help our work, you are able to do so right here. You may as well subscribe to our Patreon channel right here. Subscribe to our Publication and observe us on Bluesky right here, X right here and Mastodon right here.
