Rural Wisconsin homelessness and the struggle to do ‘extra with much less’

Studying Time: 15 minutes

Click on right here to learn highlights from the story

• Wisconsin’s homeless inhabitants has been rising since 2021. Wisconsin Watch is reporting for the primary time the official rely taken in January 2024 rose once more to greater than 5,000 for the primary time since 2017.

• Counties exterior Milwaukee, Dane and Racine account for 60% of the state’s homeless inhabitants, but solely have 23% of the beds.

• Because the nationwide and state focus has shifted to a “housing first” technique for addressing homelessness, rural communities with fewer shelter beds, case staff and assets are struggling to seek out reasonably priced housing for these in want.

• Shelter suppliers say doable options embody bypassing county governments for state reimbursements, consolidating a number of definitions of homelessness, and extra constant and proportional state funding.

Final winter, Eric Zieroth wearing as many layers as he may and stayed beneath a down blanket every night time. He realized it was the easiest way to maintain heat whereas residing in his automotive in far northwestern Wisconsin. 

Throughout these chilly months, he and his then-20-year-old daughter Christina Hubbell needed to wake, begin the automobile and blast the warmth a number of occasions an evening earlier than shutting it off once more. 

For over a 12 months, the pair often parked their PT Cruiser — a automotive older than Hubbell that Zieroth, 47, referred to as “a shoebox on wheels” — in a nook spot at a public boat touchdown on Lengthy Lake. The lot is lower than a mile from the agricultural metropolis of Shell Lake, with a inhabitants of lower than 1,400.

Down a mud highway and tucked into the woods, they slept on the secluded launch to remain out of the way in which within the city the place they spent most of their lives. Now, as a result of they’re homeless, they’ve been ostracized for showering, parking and sleeping in public locations.

Washburn County has no homeless shelters, and so they don’t have household to stick with. Hubbell’s mother and Zieroth divorced in 2022. The next 12 months, when Hubbell was 19, her mother advised her to start out paying lease or go away. 

Hubbell’s job at a Greenback Basic in Shell Lake — their solely supply of earnings — retains them from relocating to a shelter in one other county. They’re on a waitlist for a low-income housing unit. 

Zieroth is awaiting a surgical procedure that can permit him to get again to work. With no approach to heal or preserve the wound clear, he stated he couldn’t get the operation whereas residing in his automotive. If it weren’t for his daughter, the previous mechanic stated he might need thought of committing a criminal offense and getting booked into jail as an alternative of spending one other winter within the automobile. 

“There’s no approach I may do it once more,” Zieroth stated. “I had to determine one thing else this 12 months.”

In rural Wisconsin, homelessness is usually hidden behind a veil of people and households who’re sofa browsing and sleeping of their automobiles as an alternative of sleeping on metropolis streets or tenting out in parks. Assets are few and much between, shelters are all the time full, and funding generally is a important problem on the native, state and federal degree.

After falling for years, the state’s estimated homeless inhabitants has been rising since 2021. This previous 12 months it rose once more from 4,861 in 2023 to five,037. Within the “stability” of the state — all 69 counties exterior Milwaukee, Racine and Dane — the homeless inhabitants elevated from 2,938 people in 2023 to three,201 in 2024, in line with information Wisconsin Watch obtained from the area’s continuum of care group, which conducts homeless counts annually.

Regardless of accounting for over 60% of the state’s homeless inhabitants in 2023, these largely rural counties collectively comprise simply 23% of the state’s supportive housing models — long-term housing fashions with on-site supportive companies, which specialists say is the easiest way to deal with continual homelessness. However offering long-term housing and companies on prime of shelter is an costly, labor-intensive activity for small, rural suppliers with restricted funding.

Based on the Division of Public Instruction’s newest information, 18,455 college students skilled homelessness in the course of the 2022-23 college 12 months — a quantity that has elevated annually since 2020. Some 11,000 of those college students reside in districts exterior of Milwaukee, Madison, Racine and Inexperienced Bay.

The annual information collected on homelessness are an undercount, particularly in rural areas, stated Mary Frances Kenion, vice chairman of coaching and technical help on the Nationwide Alliance to Finish Homelessness. Meaning much less funding for already deprived smaller communities. 

“The place there’s extra focus of individuals, that’s all the time going to drive funding, as a result of we now have block grant funding that’s straight tied to the census,” Kenion advised Wisconsin Watch. 

Regardless of rural communities having fewer nonprofits than city ones, shelters and housing help packages are main the way in which to deal with the expanse of homelessness in rural Wisconsin. 

“Funding and entry to assets is a problem … however there are some actually brilliant spots in rural communities, as a result of they’re doing extra with much less,” Kenion stated. “We’re seeing a ton of innovation and resilience simply by advantage of them being positioned to do extra with much less.” 

However shelter administrators and anti-poverty advocates face many hurdles in the case of funding, assets and help.

Rural shelter suppliers throughout the state recognized a number of options to the issue: Chopping out county governments because the intermediary for state reimbursements, rising the supply of latest rental models, consolidating a number of definitions of homelessness, extra constant and proportional state funding, and help with case administration are only a few.

Level-in-time counts, federal funding and HUD 

The annual “point-in-time” (PIT) homeless counts are collected by continuum of care organizations throughout the nation on a single night time over the last week of January. Wisconsin has 4 designated organizations with three protecting Milwaukee, Dane and Racine counties and one for the opposite 69 counties. 

The counts are submitted to Congress and the U.S. Division of Housing and City Growth (HUD) for consideration and funding determinations. They’re meant to incorporate these residing in momentary shelters, in addition to unsheltered folks residing on the road, however don’t embody folks in different sheltered conditions. These residing in automobiles are sometimes missed. 

“They’re sometimes both of their automotive or they’re on anyone’s sofa,” stated Jenny Fasula, govt director of Wisconsin’s Basis for Rural Housing. “Folks on the couches don’t rely in your PIT counts as a result of they’re ‘housed.’ Folks in automobiles in rural areas — I don’t even know the place you’d discover them, besides perhaps a Walmart parking zone.”

Since 2009, HUD — the principle federal company that handles homelessness — has focused everlasting supportive housing packages with long-term, sustainable companies like case administration for federal funding. The nationwide shift from momentary housing packages displays a broadly adopted “housing first” strategy — that the safety of a everlasting shelter is the primary, essential step earlier than folks can deal with the basis causes of their homelessness. 

“Non permanent housing packages shifted their gears in direction of that different sort of service so they might proceed to function and get funding to function,” Wisconsin Coverage Discussion board researcher Donald Cramer advised Wisconsin Watch. 

Whereas everlasting housing packages successfully lowered Wisconsin’s homeless inhabitants in each rural and concrete areas earlier than the pandemic, the shift hasn’t been simple for rural shelters which can be strapped for money and assets.

“As a shelter, when you will have 50 folks, it’s inconceivable to have the funding to rent case managers which can be actually concerned and in a position to actually help folks,” stated Michael Corridor, a former Waupaca County shelter employee and director of Affect Wisconsin — a nonprofit offering housing and restoration companies in a six-county rural area. 

“We’re small,” stated Adam Schnabel, vice chairman of a homeless shelter in Taylor County, including that with out extra workers, the shelter can’t have somebody accountable for post-departure case administration to verify folks keep in housing.

“We’re looking for volunteer case managers,” stated Kimberly Fitzgerald, interim director of the Rusk County Lighthouse shelter. “Folks to volunteer their time, to work at no cost, to do case administration. Good luck with that.” 

Restrictions on federal funding and a number of definitions of homelessness are one other barrier for rural homeless suppliers, stated Millie Rounsville, CEO of Northwest Wisconsin Group Companies Company. 

The federal McKinney-Vento Homeless Help Act defines homelessness particularly for youth as minor youngsters who “lack a hard and fast, common, and ample nighttime residence.” However HUD defines homelessness in a number of classes: 1) a person or household who is straight away homeless and with out shelter and a couple of) these at imminent threat of homelessness. Consolidating these definitions is vital, in line with Rounsville. 

Homeless youngsters and households within the rural area surrounding Superior are usually doubled up in some sort of housing, Rounsville stated. Whereas they typically meet the McKinney-Vento definition of homeless, they’re thought of class two homeless below HUD’s definitions. 

However with a view to qualify for HUD-funded Fast Rehousing packages, people should fall below class one.

“The funding must be versatile,” Rounsville stated. “We are able to’t assume that each group throughout the nation has the identical want.”

To offer everlasting supportive housing and obtain funding, shelters and nonprofits additionally need to serve and doc chronically homeless populations. Based on HUD, which means a member of the family has to have a documented incapacity. Suppliers like Rounsville are moreover required to offer third-party verification that somebody has been class one homeless for a 12 months or extra.

“If you happen to had been in a bigger metropolis the place you will have plenty of shelters or road outreach, that third-party verification could be loads simpler than once you’re in a rural group,” Rounsville stated.

It’s a housing challenge

Rural Wisconsin is missing reasonably priced, liveable properties.

“While you layer the restricted footprint of service suppliers in a rural group, filled with a housing provide that’s already inadequate and persevering with to shrink, that creates an ideal storm for rising numbers of individuals experiencing homelessness,” Kenion stated. 

Suppliers in Rusk County, Taylor County, Bayfield County and Waupaca County stated that with out low-income choices and out there rental models, they typically can’t get folks into everlasting housing.

“As quick as models open up, they get crammed,” Fitzgerald stated. “In Ladysmith particularly, there are subsequent to no rental models. So even when anyone did get permitted for the housing program, the place are we going to place them?”

Amongst affordability and lack points, rural areas are additionally house to the state’s growing older housing inventory. 

“The housing inventory may be very previous,” Fasula stated. “So now you will have increased vitality payments. And the lease could also be decrease, however your vitality invoice is twice as a lot.” 

Her work on the Basis for Rural Housing supplies one-time emergency rental help to stop evictions and homelessness throughout the state. 

“Folks stereotype them to suppose ‘Oh, we now have these packages as a result of folks don’t know how you can handle their cash.’ It’s not that,” Fasula stated. “These are people that are available in that simply have a disaster. … They don’t have something to fall again on. Any little hiccup is a huge impact for them financially.”

The inspiration is partially funded by the state’s important help grant program, which is awarded to only one eligible company in Wisconsin. Fasula stated the muse nonetheless depends on many non-public funding sources.

Whereas working to ultimately afford an house in Shell Lake, Hubbell is making $13.50 an hour on the Greenback Basic, however solely scheduled to work 20 hours per week. The residing wage calculation for one grownup in Washburn County is $19.45 an hour working 40 hours per week, in line with the MIT residing wage calculator.

“Homelessness is a housing challenge. It’s a symptom of an economic system and insurance policies that aren’t working,” Kenion stated. “Sure, housing prices are usually decrease in rural communities, however so do wages.”

State funding 

Within the state’s 2023-25 biennial price range, the Republican-controlled Legislature rejected Democratic Gov. Tony Evers’ suggestions to spend some $24 million on emergency shelter and housing grants, in addition to homeless case administration companies and rental help for unhoused veterans.

The Legislature additionally nixed $250 million Evers proposed for reasonably priced workforce housing and residential rehabilitation grants.

The state funds two fundamental grants for homeless shelters and housing yearly. The State Shelter Subsidy Grant (SSSG) receives round $1.6 million per 12 months, and the Housing Help Program receives $900,000.

However for small shelters like Taylor Home — the one homeless shelter in rural Taylor County — Schnabel says the funding is “pennies.” The power has a steady waitlist. 

“We’re a misplaced folks up north, right here within the rural areas,” Schnabel stated. “I really feel like there’s a lot focus and so many fiscal assets offered to Dane and Milwaukee counties.” 

The north central Wisconsin shelter with a 17-person capability acquired $10,000 from SSSG this 12 months, Schnabel stated. That’s round $588 per individual. However 4 emergency shelters in Milwaukee with a mixed capability of round 392 acquired $400,000 from the $1.6 million grant whole — $1,020 per individual.

“It’s not simply native people we’re serving,” Schnabel stated. “We’re serving people from Milwaukee County, Dane County, Fox River Valley, Chippewa. They’re coming from throughout as a result of these homeless shelters are both at capability or their waitlist is simply too lengthy.”

The state’s Restoration Voucher Grant Program awarded $760,000 to grantees in 2024 to offer housing to these experiencing homelessness and battling opioid use issues. Half of those funds went to 3 suppliers in Dane, Milwaukee and Waukesha counties. 

One other state useful resource is the Homeless Case Administration Companies (HCMS) grant program, which distributes as much as 10 $50,000 grants per 12 months to shelters and packages that meet eligibility necessities.

Shelter administrators like Fitzgerald stated the state’s reliance on grant funding to deal with homelessness and housing wants isn’t sustainable for small suppliers. Whereas useful, these pots of cash shortly run out, and plenty of of them don’t cowl working prices or wages. 

“Lots of these funding sources, it’s like a primary come first serve foundation, so there isn’t cash essentially allotted to cowl our bills,” Fitzgerald stated. “When the funding runs out, we’re SOL.” 

The Lighthouse is the one homeless shelter in Rusk County. Many surrounding shelters are additionally full, and a few counties don’t have shelters in any respect, leaving folks with restricted choices. 

“As quick as we empty out, we replenish. So it’s sort of a revolving door,” Fitzgerald stated. “Our first precedence is to serve Rusk County residents, however we’re within the enterprise of serving to, so I don’t flip folks away.” 

Small shelters face county-level hurdles 

Some shelter staff and advocates say in rural Wisconsin, homelessness is addressed solely to the extent that their native governments and administrations are prepared to acknowledge the difficulty and get entangled.

“Lots of these folks go unnoticed, unchecked within the system, and there simply aren’t any county companies, particularly in our group, which can be there to assist people which can be struggling,” Corridor stated. “We, with plenty of duct tape and a shoestring, maintain it down.” 

Suppliers in a number of rural counties famous that there aren’t any shelters which can be owned or operated in any capability by native governments. Usually, Washburn County Social Companies can solely direct homeless residents like Zieroth and Hubbell to the Lakeland Household Useful resource Heart, which offered them with an inventory of shelters too far out of their attain.

“We don’t have the additional gasoline or an honest sufficient automobile to go too removed from Shell Lake,” Zieroth stated.

The Ashland Group Shelter is the one shelter in a four-county rural space. The town utilized for the federal grant funds that allowed Rounsville’s company to accumulate the shelter, however she famous that if it hadn’t taken that step, there wouldn’t be a shelter in Ashland at the moment. 

“You continue to want that county authorities saying, ‘Hey, we now have a program, we want funding,’” Cramer stated. “In case your county is just not seeking to cope with homelessness, then they’re in all probability not asking for that funding both.”

Corridor and Schnabel stated native governments must be extra concerned of their work, whether or not that be offering a county worker to function a shelter director, or just making higher use of the few assets they’ve.

Schnabel added that small shelters typically can not pay their administrators an honest wage, leading to frequent workers turnover. Taylor Home has had 4 administrators within the final 18 months, he stated. The inconsistency leaves “a foul style” within the mouth of these reviewing their grant functions.

Based on Corridor, some counties are way more prepared than others to make the most of Complete Group Companies (CCS) — a state program geared toward addressing substance abuse and psychological well being wants. This system permits counties to contract workers and case managers at native shelters who present companies resembling abilities growth and peer help. If the notes are completed correctly, the county can invoice these bills again to the state by way of BadgerCare. 

However regardless of these being reimbursable bills, some county officers both don’t know the way or are unwilling to have interaction in this system, Corridor stated. 

“The device is there, it simply must be utilized,” he stated. “Due to their unwillingness to strive one thing, it oftentimes finally ends up having to inform folks ‘no,’ and we’re shifting them to a different county.”

He added that permitting native shelters that serve these lined below BadgerCare to invoice the state straight for these companies as an alternative of counting on the county to provoke it “would resolve the issue tomorrow.”

Corridor additionally famous that county governments can use their opioid settlement funds to offer housing and shelter to these with eligible wants, but some have as an alternative spent it on different issues. 

Waupaca County, for instance, advised Wisconsin Watch it has spent practically $100,000 in opioid settlement funds on consciousness campaigns, coaching, a counselor place and tools that helps native police shortly establish narcotics within the subject.

Grant funding is usually allotted to regional “father or mother” organizations, like a Salvation Military, which then distribute the cash to native nonprofits and shelters. However Schnabel stated the state should pressure the hand of counties that “select to not see homelessness.” 

“By requiring that these funds undergo the county to be disbursed to the homeless shelter, it forces the county to have a relationship and have pores and skin within the recreation with the shelters,” he stated. 

One other problem is that some small communities like Ashland reject homeless shelters, assuming they are going to convey adverse footprints.

“There’s going to be needles, the neighborhood homes are going to be robbed, youngsters are going to be ran over on the freeway,” Rounsville stated. “There’s all types of issues that got here up after we had been doing the change of use for this resort to turn into a shelter. It was one thing that not everyone needed to see in the neighborhood.” 

The small metropolis of Clintonville permitted an ordinance final winter implementing a 60-day restrict on native resort stays in a six-month interval, citing drug considerations, disorderly conduct and disturbances. Many homeless people within the space are put up in these inns. 

“We’re making an attempt to determine, what are we going to do with these 50 folks this winter when the police departments come by way of and say they need to get out,” Corridor stated. 

Research estimate that yearly, somebody experiencing continual homelessness prices a group $30,000 to $50,000, in line with the Interagency Council on Homelessness. But for every one who is homeless, everlasting supportive housing prices communities $20,000 per 12 months.

“These are our neighbors in any group, and when they’re not homeless and they’re thriving, they reinvest that into the economic system, into the group, into the neighborhood,” Kenion stated.

Whereas typically doing extra with much less, native nonprofits are nonetheless those which can be constructed to do that work, Corridor stated.

“There is no such thing as a answer. There is no such thing as a algorithm to get us to a solution,” Schnabel stated. “However what we all know is that there must be a spot that they’ll go to be secure, and have heat, safe housing till they’ll get again on their toes.”

Shunned by their group

In June, Zieroth and Hubbell pulled their automotive right into a Shell Lake gasoline station parking zone to sleep, shortly earlier than a police officer was referred to as and arrived to inform them they had been trespassing and needed to go away. 

In August, the daddy and daughter stopped on the Shell Lake ATV Campground to make use of the general public showers, when a campground worker entered and demanded that Zieroth get his daughter and go away. The worker referred to as Shell Lake police, who escorted him off the property. 

A resident residing subsequent to the boat launch the place they stayed ultimately took challenge with them parking their automotive on the public lot. In October, Hubbell stated the house owner stormed into the Greenback Basic whereas she was working and advised her they couldn’t sleep there anymore, threatening to name the police.

And one night time after discovering a gaggle fishing on the boat launch, the pair determined to drive to a different public touchdown in Burnett County the place they parked and slept. Nonetheless below their blankets, they woke the following morning to a DNR officer and county sheriff’s deputy approaching, asking about Zieroth’s “drug of selection.” Based on Wisconsin Court docket System data, Zieroth served time in jail for housebreaking as a 21-year-old, however has by no means confronted drug-related costs.

They had been advised to depart. 

“They simply didn’t need us on this space. We’re lower than a mile from the place we grew up, and from the place she went to highschool and graduated,” Zieroth stated, pointing to his daughter. “I’ve made my life right here … every part factors to ‘get out.’”

Whereas nonetheless homeless, the pair had been lucky sufficient to discover a momentary place to remain because the climate will get colder — a small room within the unfinished basement of an acquaintance who didn’t wish to see them residing out of their automotive. They’re joined by their canine Bella, who Zieroth received’t abandon after she woke him the night time his camper caught hearth in 2022, permitting him to flee and certain saving his life. 

Zieroth and Hubbell have an previous mattress, a recliner and a toilet for now. However their most cherished consolation is that the room is heated — one thing they don’t take as a right after a winter spent of their automotive. 

With a roof over their heads, Zieroth hopes to lastly get the surgical procedure he wants, however he’s not sure of how lengthy they’ll keep. 

They insist on paying the owners $50 per week — all they’ll afford — for letting them keep within the basement. Zieroth makes use of his abilities as a mechanic to make things better across the property, and Hubbell picks objects up for them on the Greenback Basic each time she will.

As soon as healed, he desires to get again to work and purchase a property of his personal, however his first precedence is his daughter. After getting on her toes, Hubbell hopes to go to cosmetology college in Rice Lake.

“She has her entire life forward of her and expertise has taught me that some actual dangerous beginnings get actually good endings, and he or she deserves a great one,” Zieroth stated.

Republish This Story

Republish our articles at no cost, on-line or in print, below a Artistic Commons license.