As Jill Trapp steered her pickup truck down the purple dust roads of southeast Oklahoma, she raised a hand to greet a passing neighbor — a calf roper who as soon as made it to the Nationwide Finals Rodeo.
She drove on, passing a modest cowboy church the place Sunday sermons share house with nation music and the scent of brisket.
Then, rising among the many cedar and elm timber, got here a well-recognized and unwelcome sight: a row of lengthy, grey, windowless rooster homes, every longer than two soccer fields.
“I attempt to not dwell on it. I fake they’re not right here,” Trapp mentioned.
However quickly her truck jolted because it rolled via a pothole — one in every of many left behind by the fixed move of semitrucks hauling tons of of hundreds of chickens via the realm.
On this nook of the state, the poultry trade is tough to disregard.
Inside a roughly 25-mile radius of the southeast Oklahoma city of Idabel, there are 59 industrial poultry farms — greater than half constructed within the final 15 years, sometimes bigger than older operations. Collectively, they increase practically 7.4 million birds at most capability. All however six develop chickens for Tyson Meals, the biggest meat firm within the nation; the opposite six farms provide Pilgrim’s Pleasure, a Colorado-based, multinational meals firm.
Past the standard considerations these farms increase — air pollution and odors from the huge quantities of waste they generate, issues which have sparked lawsuits in Oklahoma and different states — residents in McCurtain County have one other fear: the aquifer.
The area’s fast progress — pushed by poultry farms, marijuana farming, and a tourism growth in Hochatown — is placing mounting strain on native water provides. And locals are beginning to surprise simply how a lot pressure the aquifer water can take.
Trade-friendly legal guidelines and nominal penalties have allowed corporations like Tyson to function with little accountability. Minimal oversight from state companies usually means residents have little details about whether or not the economic poultry farms are polluting or depleting the area’s groundwater.
“I’m involved that we’re going to overuse our waters and never have sustainability for the longer term,” mentioned Charlette Hearne, a outstanding water rights advocate primarily based in Damaged Bow.
Mud, flies, and vans thundering via the evening
When Trapp and her husband constructed their residence about 20 years in the past, they have been drawn to the realm’s remoteness and luxurious panorama — the proper place, they thought, to begin a household and lift cattle and yard chickens.
However 5 years after settling in, a person knocked on their door.
He informed them he had bought the property subsequent door and deliberate to construct six giant rooster homes. He additionally requested them to not increase any chickens, warning they may infect his flock and jeopardize his enterprise.
“This preliminary disappointment didn’t examine to what occurred within the final 15 years,” Trapp mentioned final month at a neighborhood assembly in Idabel, attended by greater than 150 individuals, together with officers from the Oklahoma Water Sources Board.
She went on to explain the overwhelming smells that fill her yard at any time when one of many farm’s rooster homes is cleaned out, the swarms of flies and layers of mud that decide on the partitions of her home, and the noise from vans hauling birds all through the evening.
“Every contract grower is required to adjust to federal, state, and native legal guidelines, together with the Oklahoma regulation to have a farm-specific Nutrient Administration Plan (NMP),” a Tyson Meals spokesperson mentioned in an announcement. “The phrases of every NMP embody necessities for storage and disposition of poultry litter, as required beneath the Oklahoma Registered Poultry Feeding Operations Act. The NMPs are developed with measures designed to stop discharge.”
The Could 1 assembly primarily centered on a proposed 12-building rooster farm, which, if constructed, would develop into the second-largest poultry operation within the space.
The farm’s house owners requested a allow from the Oklahoma Water Sources Board to make use of roughly 86 million gallons of water per yr, equal to the typical water utilization of 785 four-person households.
In contrast to most different rooster farms in Oklahoma, the cluster of farms in McCurtain County sits atop a regulated aquifer, the Antlers. These farms use water from the aquifer for chook consumption, sanitation and cooling the rooster homes.
The present restrict for permitted water withdrawals from the Antlers aquifer is 2.1 acre-feet per acre, or greater than 680,000 gallons of water for every acre of land — the very best allocation of any groundwater basin within the state. State officers set that restrict in 1995 by dividing the aquifer’s estimated whole quantity by the acreage above it.
“Our regulation is designed to deplete the aquifer. It’s designed to mine the water for financial functions,” mentioned Sara Gibson, basic counsel for the Oklahoma Water Sources Board, throughout the assembly.
For Hearne, this admission makes one factor clear: Oklahoma’s water legal guidelines must be up to date to replicate the state’s progress and shield its pure assets.
She factors to the Arbuckle-Simpson aquifer — adjoining to the Antlers — as successful story.
Within the Nineteen Eighties, native advocates pushed for federal recognition of the aquifer because the area’s solely viable consuming water supply — a designation that later helped residents push for a complete hydrological examine and block a plan to export water.
That examine led to a major change: the aquifer’s withdrawal restrict dropped from 2.0 acre-feet to only 0.2 — the bottom within the state.
To Hearne, it’s an easy lesson of how science ought to information water coverage.
“You’ve acquired to know your month-to-month, each day, differences due to the season earlier than you possibly can problem permits correctly,” she mentioned.
However maybe the largest shock for these on the assembly got here with the revelation that the majority poultry operations sometimes don’t apply for water permits in any respect.
The ‘home use’ loophole lets industrial farms pump water with out permits — and with out limits
Lobbying by the poultry trade within the Nineties led to a loophole the place a allow isn’t required if a property proprietor claims the water is for “home use” reasonably than a enterprise.
“If the farm is doing enterprise as Bob and Mary Jo Smith, they don’t want a allow. In the event that they’re doing enterprise as Smith Poultry LLC, they do,” Gibson defined.
Whereas the 74 industrial poultry farms in McCurtain County are owned by particular person farmers, they increase chickens beneath contract with companies like Tyson Meals and Pilgrim’s Pleasure, which tightly management their operations. Solely 4 at the moment have water permits, with a fifth pending for the deliberate 12-house rooster facility.
Not solely does “home use” permit a farm to function with out a water allow, however the operation can pull greater than twice the quantity of water from the aquifer in contrast to what’s allowed beneath an agricultural use allow.
In apply, the scenario is even murkier. Many farms registered as LLCs — which ought to have permits — additionally lack them, a spot that Gibson says she is working with Oklahoma Division of Agriculture, Meals and Forestry (ODAFF) to deal with. The few farms which have utilized for permits have probably performed so to exceed the bounds allowed beneath home use.
In the meantime, water utilization is actually limitless: the OWRB depends on an honor system for water reporting — the 4 poultry farms in McCurtain County with water permits reported zero use in 2024 —, and the company has by no means revoked a allow or penalized anybody for exceeding their allowed water utilization.
“The water used on farms is required to be obtained from lawfully acquired sources,” a Tyson Meals spokesperson mentioned.
Final yr, Gov. Kevin Stitt vetoed a invoice that might have required metering gadgets on all groundwater wells throughout the state — a transfer praised by the agriculture trade and the Oklahoma Farm Bureau.
The Republican governor rejected the invoice regardless of considerations over intensifying droughts and the agriculture trade’s heavy water use, notably in northwest Oklahoma. The area just lately skilled its second-driest interval in over a century. And its essential water supply, the Ogallala Aquifer, has been considerably depleted by Seaboard Meals.
Even when there have been stricter guidelines and required metering, there is probably not sufficient cash for enforcement or aquifer research, based on Gibson.
The OWRB’s annual price range — excluding supplemental funds for water and wastewater infrastructure and different applications — has ranged from $5 million to over $8 million in recent times. The company mentioned it has fewer than 20 workers members to assessment a mean of 250 allow functions and amendments annually, examine points and conduct fieldwork.
“We used to have subject places of work across the state. We don’t have these anymore,” Gibson mentioned.
E. coli within the properly — who’s accountable?
Many attendees on the assembly expressed considerations not solely about water amount but in addition water high quality.
OWRB doesn’t consider water high quality earlier than issuing a allow — it doesn’t check for consuming water contaminants or assess the potential impression of runoff. And if an aquifer is suspected of being contaminated by a poultry farm, oversight falls to ODAFF.
Following the Could 1 assembly in Idabel, Trapp determined to check her properly water. The outcomes got here again optimistic for E. coli.
The lab notified her that the presence of the micro organism posed a “main well being concern,” although it couldn’t decide the supply of the contamination.
Requested whether or not proximity to a poultry farm could possibly be the trigger, Teena Gunter, basic counsel at ODAFF, responded:
“[E. coli] isn’t widespread in properly water close to poultry farms,” she mentioned. “Poultry farms are thought of no-discharge amenities. So for something to run off from that course of could be a significant violation.”
However Jayme Cannon, an environmental scientist with the Oklahoma Division of Environmental High quality, says properly house owners residing close to poultry farms must be involved about micro organism like E. coli.
“If E. coli is persistently current within the properly, sure, that could be a trigger for concern.” Cannon mentioned. “E. coli is an acute well being threat and whether it is current in water, the water shouldn’t be used for consuming or consumption.”
Final yr, an Oklahoma conservation group discovered elevated ranges of E. coli and enterococcus in components of jap Oklahoma with a excessive focus of poultry farms — a sign of animal feces contamination.
Trapp plans to retest her water to rule out contamination brought on by current storms. However even when the micro organism returns, proving it got here from the Tyson farm subsequent door could be tough — and previous violations by poultry farms have not often led to severe penalties.
In 2023, ODAFF fined 14 poultry farms between $100 and $300 every for failing to submit or submitting late their litter administration studies. The very best tremendous, $600, was issued to a farm that didn’t renew its license or file any studies for 3 years. It was the one enforcement motion taken by the company.
“Businesses are restricted in what they will do due to the authorities they’ve been granted by the legislature,” mentioned Shanon Phillips, director of the water high quality division on the Oklahoma Conservation Fee.
A invoice handed final yr elevated the fines ODAFF can impose to $1,000 and gave the company extra authority to behave when poultry farms break the foundations.
However the identical invoice additionally granted poultry corporations authorized safety, shielding them from lawsuits so long as they adjust to rules.
That’s troubling, critics say, as a result of even when farms comply with the foundations, air pollution continues to be an issue.
In 2005, then-Legal professional Basic Drew Edmondson sued a gaggle of poultry corporations over elevated phosphorus ranges within the Illinois River watershed brought on by rooster litter used as fertilizer. Rainfall and irrigation washed phosphorus from the litter into close by streams and rivers, fueling algae blooms and degrading water high quality.
After 18 years of litigation, a U.S. District Decide dominated in favor of Oklahoma, holding poultry corporations — together with Tyson Meals — answerable for polluting the watershed.
The businesses pushed again, citing enhancements since 2005. However at a listening to final yr, six scientific consultants testified that rooster litter air pollution stays a significant issue. They offered knowledge displaying rising phosphorus ranges, with some arguing {that a} ban on the usage of rooster litter as fertilizer could be the solely resolution.
The identical system that broke earlier farmers now recruits new ones
Throughout this yr’s state legislative session, Sen. George Burns, R-Pollard, launched two payments aimed toward stopping the expansion of the poultry trade in his district after listening to from his constituents.
One invoice proposed a moratorium on all new poultry farm functions, whereas the opposite would have required poultry farm house owners to supply proof of residency.
“These individuals are from Vietnam. They’re getting 1% loans. They arrive in right here and put these mega operations throughout southeast Oklahoma — and they’re unlawful,” Burns mentioned throughout a February Agriculture Committee listening to. He later referred to the farms as “filthy operations.”
However the senator didn’t current any proof that the poultry farms have been working illegally or that their house owners have been undocumented residents. Each payments finally failed in committee.
The payments, even when handed, wouldn’t have addressed the water considerations voiced by residents of McCurtain County.
Brad Phillips, who has lived on his land in McCurtain County since he was 10 years previous, challenged the groundwater allow for the deliberate mega rooster farm subsequent to his property. He and one of many candidates, Duc Minh Tran, appeared at a listening to on the Oklahoma Water Sources Board places of work in Oklahoma Metropolis.
“We’re at all times about three weeks from a drought… it looks as if in these newer instances my inventory ponds go drier faster,” Phillips mentioned throughout his testimony.
Tran, who speaks restricted English, gave temporary responses throughout questioning. However after the listening to, his legal professional, Bryan Nowlin, mentioned Tran is an American citizen, is following the regulation, and desires to pursue the American dream by constructing a profitable enterprise.
Throughout the nation, a rising share of poultry farmers are Asian immigrants, notably Vietnamese and Laotian. Sen. Burns’ remarks replicate the suspicions of some McCurtain County residents, a lot of whom have both filed for chapter as poultry farmers or know others who’ve. They query why a brand new wave of growers is keen to tackle thousands and thousands in debt to construct farms for a similar corporations that drove others into monetary smash.
These tensions have been exacerbated by studies of undocumented staff and labor exploitation at marijuana farms, many operated by Asian immigrants.
Examine Midwest couldn’t independently confirm whether or not immigrant farmers obtain low-interest loans, particular bonuses or subsidies. However many seem to function beneath the identical contract system that has lengthy exploited rooster farmers.
Amanda Hitt, a lawyer who has spent greater than a decade representing whistleblowers within the meals system, urged the USDA to gather up to date demographic knowledge on poultry contract growers after working with purchasers who communicate little or no English and have been subjected to exploitative, and infrequently deceptive contracts.
“They’re requested to only signal paperwork and so they simply go forward. They don’t know what they’re signing. They don’t know why they’re signing. They only signal it,” Hitt mentioned. “They’re very keen to take orders and directives and do greater than their white counterparts.”
Jack Brown, who lives close to the city of Valiant, has been a poultry farmer for Tyson since 1995. Final yr, the corporate informed him that his rooster homes have been too previous and so they have been ending his contract.
He mentioned the early years have been worthwhile. However then the corporate began penalizing him, withholding chickens for six months at a time for 2 consecutive years, with out rationalization. They stored demanding upgrades, which he made — spending $200,000 — till he may not afford to maintain up.
“After I constructed my (rooster) home it value $250,000,” Brown mentioned. “Now it prices practically $1 million. So I couldn’t sustain with the expertise and manufacturing.”
Along with his essential supply of earnings gone, Brown, a retired electrician, has returned to work refurbishing generators.
Brown is aware of a few of the newer Asian poultry farmers within the space and maintains pleasant relationships with them — as does Jill Trapp, regardless of her frustrations with the Tyson farm subsequent door.
Trapp, whose neighboring poultry farm is owned by a Vietnamese man, describes a heat relationship together with her neighbor. They trade Christmas presents, and she or he chats along with his son when he visits, since he speaks fluent English. Her problem isn’t with the farmers themselves — it’s with the businesses behind them.
“Firms simply have this particular person to make it appear like they’re a bit rooster farmer, however they’re not,” Trapp mentioned. “Large companies, the massive rooster homes and marijuana farms are available and so they all dig wells… Now, that’s not a really untypical factor in agriculture. However they’re not people anymore.”
Republish our articles free of charge, on-line or in print.
