I’m a longtime Carnival cruiser. Right here’s what I considered my first MSC cruise

I simply cheated on my favourite cruise line.

I’ve cruised with Carnival Cruise Line since 1998, starting with the inaugural crusing of Carnival Paradise. Most of my household’s many cruises through the years have been on board a Carnival ship. We frequently selected the road due to its budget-friendly fares and the comfort of driving to its many U.S. house ports. Plus, we love the number of meals choices and the celebratory vibe, and may by no means appear to get sufficient of the Alchemy Bar.

However currently, I have been fascinated by one other cruise line. MSC Cruises is commonly in comparison with Carnival as a result of it gives a fairly priced cruise trip and offers many onboard actions that enchantment to households and cruisers in search of a enjoyable environment. Ever since this Europe-based cruise line started cruising from the U.S., it has been on my radar.

I lastly had the prospect to pattern MSC for myself throughout a seven-night Caribbean cruise on MSC Seascape. My cabin was situated throughout the MSC Yacht Membership, the road’s upscale retreat discovered on MSC Cruises’ bigger ships. Nevertheless, my weeklong crusing supplied ample time to discover the ship past my Yacht Membership cocoon.

Would MSC turn into my new favourite line, or will Carnival eternally stay my first-choice cruise line? Learn on to find what I liked about MSC and what made me miss being on a Carnival cruise.

MSC Yacht Membership is the place it is at

I used to be utterly smitten with the MSC Yacht Membership. Of the almost 30 cruises I’ve taken throughout a number of traces, this was my favourite general cabin expertise. As a Yacht Membership visitor, I loved a non-public pool and sundeck space, unique eating on the Prime Sail restaurant (which was prime notch), and devoted lounge and bar areas with free drinks. I additionally had entry to 24-hour concierge and butler companies (eating and spa reservations, unpacking and repacking, morning espresso supply, and extra), in addition to a devoted concierge and visitor companies desk.

Associated: All the things you have to find out about MSC Cruises cabins and suites

Yacht Membership cabins and suites additionally include bathrobes and slippers, which I wore daily. I additionally made good use of the in-cabin Nespresso machine and a complimentary minibar stocked with juice, beer, soda and bottled water (flat and glowing), in addition to combined nuts, Pringles and Toblerone chocolate. Different Yacht Membership perks I appreciated have been free Wi-Fi, premium alcohol packages and complimentary entry to Aurea Spa’s thermal suite.

Carnival does not have a product that comes near MSC Yacht Membership. Passengers who ebook an Excel Suite on choose Carnival ships could have entry to Loft 19, a retreat-style deck house that options an infinity whirlpool. Nevertheless, the house lacks complimentary eating and free drinks. Additionally, of us not staying in Excel Suites can purchase passes to Loft 19, which type of minimizes the exclusivity issue.

Each day Publication

Reward your inbox with the TPG Each day e-newsletter

Be a part of over 700,000 readers for breaking information, in-depth guides and unique offers from TPG’s consultants

My week within the MSC Yacht Membership made me rethink my cabin wants, and I would truly ebook a collection on my subsequent Carnival cruise.

Associated: All the things you wish to find out about cabins and suites on Carnival Cruise Line ships

Carnival’s free meals takes the cake

I am satisfied that Carnival offers essentially the most worth to its clients by means of its meals choices. The road’s complimentary eating venues are in depth and supply a powerful array of cuisines — all included within the fare. I’ve eaten many meals throughout eight Carnival ships over the previous a number of years, they usually’ve been persistently good, if not nice.

Past incredible foremost eating and buffet choices, we all the time discover scrumptious free choices at Man’s Burger Joint and BlueIguana Cantina (burritos, tacos and bowls). Actually, these two outposts are our conventional first-meal-on-the-ship lunch spots on embarkation day.

The one included-in-fare eating on MSC Seascape is in the primary eating venues and on the Market Buffet space. The remaining 5 eating places have been added-fee choices — Hola! Tacos & Cantina (Mexican), Kaito Sushi Bar and Kaito Teppanyaki (Asian), Butcher’s Reduce (steakhouse), and Ocean Cay (seafood).

I sampled complimentary sea-day brunch on each Carnival and MSC. I discovered Carnival to supply a greater expertise — the meals was tastier, and the service was extra environment friendly.

I additionally made some extent to strive MSC’s model of the chocolate lava cake provided on the Butcher’s Reduce steakhouse menu. Whereas the dessert was scrumptious, I want Carnival’s tackle it — the road’s well-known melting chocolate cake. The “lava” part of MSC’s dessert was runnier than Carnival’s model. So, once I mixed the vanilla ice cream with the cake, it shortly turned a soupy mess. Carnival’s cake-to-lava ratio — a bit heavier on the cake with the correct amount of lava — soaks up the ice cream a bit higher.

One menu merchandise the place MSC stole the highlight from Carnival is the made-to-order plant-based burger provided at Market Buffet on MSC Seascape. The soy-based burger was incredible and tasted just like a beef burger. Each veggie burger this pescatarian has ordered on a Carnival cruise was a disappointment — dry and flavorless.

Swimming pools and splash zones have been a near-tie

It is easy to have a blast on each traces’ waterslides and splash areas. Our children are grown, however I consider you are by no means too outdated to hit the waterslides. That is why I prefer it when top-deck watery zones are close to a foremost pool space, as they typically are on Carnival ships. When the solar will get to be an excessive amount of, a fast zip down a waterslide is simply steps away.

I liked MSC Seascape’s foremost pool, particularly the round water fountain island at one finish. I additionally preferred that the pool had an prolonged shallow-water ledge round it for cooling off with out leaping in. Nevertheless, the ship’s foremost waterslides have been within the Pirates Cove pool space, separate from the primary pool. The Pirates Cove house felt extra like an indoor water park than a sunny cruise ship pool, which made it much less interesting to me.

Carnival remains to be my favourite on the subject of water-based, top-deck enjoyable … with one exception.

In my ebook, MSC Seascape’s adults-only infinity pool space wins the bliss prize over Carnival’s Serenity Retreat. The aft infinity pool options half-submerged loungers and gives an expansive deck space with loads of spots to absorb outstanding views of the horizon.

Carnival’s Serenity Retreat space primarily options sizzling tubs, in addition to a slew of loungers, daybeds, hammocks and clamshells. Solely choose ships have swimming pools on their adults-only decks. Whereas the Serenity Retreat space offers a soothing, kid-free expertise, Seascape’s infinity pool feels extra upscale and unique.

I would have enjoyable with both line

Carnival could be the Enjoyable Ship line, however I did have a blast on MSC Seascape. Each traces showcase a bevy of theme events, theater productions and crew-led actions, and I did my greatest to hit as many celebrations and gatherings as potential.

I am nicely versed in Carnival’s ’80s events, that are a few of the liveliest soirees I’ve ever attended. Nevertheless, Seascape’s white celebration undoubtedly matched Carnival’s vitality. The actions employees members with each traces did an unimaginable job hyping everybody up and inspiring us all to let unfastened and have a good time.

As for general nightlife, I want Carnival. Seascape’s bars and lounges continually buzzed with company, however none of them provided a “theme,” which is one thing I gravitate towards.

For instance, the ship’s Champagne & Wine Bar on Deck 7 just about resembled a typical atrium bar. Except for two close by high-top tables with everlasting Champagne bottles as decor, nothing appeared to offer it that additional “oomph” to make you’re feeling such as you’re in a particular venue. I missed having a “go-to” venue like Carnival’s Alchemy Bar or the vigorous sing-along Piano Bar. Whereas I loved Seascape’s watering holes (particularly the sports activities bar, which is uncommon for me), I pined a bit for Carnival’s bar scene.

Backside line

If I am trustworthy, Carnival will possible all the time be my one real love. The road’s onboard eating has by no means let me down, particularly on the subject of free meals. Our relationship has stood the check of time, and I really feel like Carnival “will get” me.

That stated, the novelty of my relationship with MSC hasn’t worn off. Seascape got here on sturdy, wooing me with that Yacht Membership exclusivity. I felt particular. Seen. I am actually trying ahead to my second date — to discover the probabilities past the Yacht Membership and see what occurs. Will it’s sufficient for me to place a hoop on it? Keep tuned.

Planning a cruise? Begin with these tales: