“I don’t have sufficient fingers to rely what was there,” says Nelia Stryzhakova as she remembers the Ukrainian city of Vovchansk, the place she has lived for the previous 40 years.
“There was a technical faculty, a medical faculty, seven colleges, many kindergartens. What number of factories did we’ve got? An oil extraction manufacturing unit, a butter manufacturing unit, a furnishings manufacturing unit, a carriage manufacturing unit, of which there have been solely two in Ukraine.”
The director of the native library, Stryzhakova, was amongst these to flee Vovchansk when Russian forces started to advance on the town in Might this yr.
Vovchansk is an administrative centre within the north-east of Ukraine, divided by the Vovcha river, and simply 5 kilometres from the Russian border. In 2022, Vovchansk had 17,000 inhabitants, many with kinfolk in Russia.
“The town is gorgeous, the persons are lovely, we had all the pieces. We didn’t even assume that in (simply) 5 days we might be blown off the bottom like that,” Stryzhakova mentioned.
Her phrases are backed up by video and social media proof that present explosion after explosion throughout the town.
Bellingcat and journalists from Agence France-Presse (AFP) bureaus in Kyiv, Kharkiv and Paris have partnered to analyze the injury within the metropolis and speak to former residents who’ve first-hand expertise of the destruction.
An evaluation of satellite tv for pc imagery means that 60 % of buildings in Vovchansk have been fully destroyed.
Partial injury was noticed on an additional 18 % of buildings, leaving simply 22 % of the town the place injury has but to be detected as of late September 2024.
Kindergartens, colleges, spiritual websites, factories and libraries have all been worn out. Movies and drone footage present a desolate panorama the place solely the burnt-out skeletons of buildings as soon as stood. Residents now dwelling as refugees in close by Kharkiv, like Stryzhakova, describe desperately fleeing the city beneath heavy bombardment.
“I took my paperwork from work and a few private objects,” Stryzhakova mentioned. “That’s all I’ve. Objects aren’t an important,”
The north of Vovchansk, the place nearly all of preventing has taken place, has been virtually totally destroyed or severely broken. The town centre additionally seems to be so severely affected that few constructions stay. In line with the town’s mayor, ninety % of the centre has been “flattened”.
Though areas south of the Vovcha river that flows by Vovchansk have been badly impacted, particularly in industrial districts and homes alongside main roads, giant pockets of intact housing are nonetheless seen.
Bellingcat used SkySat imagery from Planet Labs PBC to hold out a injury evaluation on a building-by-building foundation. The method manually mapped out injury noticed within the satellite tv for pc imagery into three classes within the map beneath – inexperienced, orange, and purple. Inexperienced corresponds with no noticed injury, orange categorises indications of injury, and purple means the destruction of a constructing (readers can zoom in and swap between satellite tv for pc imagery dates in addition to present or disguise the injury evaluation layer).
The destruction in Vovchansk soared after Russia’s most up-to-date offensive started in Might.
Extra on our Map Methodology
The method of manually mapping out injury in Vovchansk sorted the buildings noticed within the satellite tv for pc imagery into three classes – inexperienced, orange, and purple.
Inexperienced corresponds with no noticed injury. Because of this on the decision and angle of satellite tv for pc imagery used, no injury was noticed to the construction, this leaves the opportunity of injury which was not seen within the imagery.
Orange categorises indications of injury, that are assessed by a broad vary of options. This may very well be indications of superficial injury to the roof of buildings, even extending to the obvious removing of the roof, however through which the ceiling seems to be intact, stopping the satellite tv for pc from seeing contained in the partitions of the construction. Different indications of injury may very well be seen particles surrounding the constructing, notably when mixed with seen artillery affect craters.
Crimson means the destruction of a constructing. This may very well be when a constructing has been fully decreased to rubble, or when the roof has been shelled so intensely that the within of the constructing’s partitions is seen. A caveat to this rule is multi-storey condo buildings, the place indicators of maximum fireplace injury or partial collapses of the constructing’s facade can even fall beneath the purple class.
Selections on these classifications are primarily based on visible proof on the map and we can’t fully rule out the opportunity of injury having occurred that isn’t seen on the map.
Different cities and cities on the entrance line in Ukraine have confronted an analogous destiny.
Bakhmut in jap Ukraine’s Donetsk Oblast was as soon as residence to 70,000 individuals earlier than it was virtually fully destroyed throughout intense preventing in 2023.
Lieutenant Denys Yaroslavsky of Ukraine’s 57th Brigade Reconnaissance Unit fought in each Bakhmut and Vovchansk. “The tempo of destruction was so quick. What occurred in Bakhmut in two or three months occurred in Vovchansk in two or three weeks. Maybe it was because of the proximity of the border, or the rise within the variety of guided aerial bombs and the intensification of heavy fireplace,” he mentioned.
In Vovchansk, management of the city has switched between Ukrainian and Russian forces and again once more. After Russian troops rolled in firstly of the nation’s full invasion in February 2022, Ukraine compelled a retreat with an autumn counter-offensive. In Might this yr, nonetheless, Russia once more pushed ahead in direction of Vovchansk. The depth of the assault compelled residents to flee.
Ukraine hit again over the summer season months, with the fierce preventing resulting in additional destruction.
Movies posted to social media channels have documented the weapons, techniques and concentrating on which have led to the town’s close to obliteration. One video from late Might filmed from a DJI drone confirmed Russian glide bombs – air-launched, typically Soviet-era weapons ordnance fitted with wings and satellite-aided navigation to increase their vary and precision – touchdown a direct hit on a multi-storey residential constructing. The video was watermarked with an emblem for Akhmat’s “Barbarian” Unmanned Aerial Car (UAV) detachment, which has posted many such movies.
Within the south of the town, a July 9 video posted to Telegram by Russian information outlet, Izvestiya, confirmed simultaneous impacts of a number of Russian FAB-500 glide bombs close to one of many important roads main into the town centre from the south.
Whereas preventing has subsided because the summer season months, the town stays removed from secure.
Latest reviews recommended Russian forces dropped an ODAB-9000 thermobaric bomb, a robust weapon designed to create an enormous blast wave over a large space, within the centre of the city in late September. Nevertheless, Ukrainian authorities disputed this declare, suggesting that such reviews have been a part of an data battle and {that a} smaller and fewer highly effective munition had been used.
‘Nobody may get us out of there’
Yaroslavsky described discovering a as soon as peaceable metropolis became a desolate wasteland.
“At the moment, Vovchansk is totally destroyed. Sure, it’s beneath management. Sure, we’ve got taken out the enemy and are attempting to take bodily management of those ruins. However the metropolis doesn’t exist. Seventeen-thousand individuals misplaced their houses, and why? As a result of somebody didn’t construct fortifications,” he mentioned, blaming “negligence or corruption”.
Journalists from AFP bureaus in Kyiv, Kharkiv and Paris met and spoke with Yaroslavsky in addition to a bunch of former Vovchansk residents throughout a current journey to Kharkiv. Many have remained there as refugees because the starting of the summer season when probably the most intense preventing started.
They supply a human face to the destruction that may be seen on satellite tv for pc imagery and in battle movies. A number of even described the fear of being confronted with a seemingly endless barrage of artillery and of seeing their neighbours perish.
Galyna Zharova, a 50-year-old native of Vovchansk, described dwelling at 16 A Stepova Avenue within the north of the town till Might 10 this yr. Harm evaluation reveals the house she and her household lived in fully wiped from the map. Latest satellite tv for pc imagery additional confirmed this.
Now dwelling in a former residence for overseas college students in Kharkiv, she recalled a dramatic story of escape.
“We have been proper on the entrance line, you perceive? Nobody may get us out of there,” Zharova mentioned.
“All of the buildings burned down and we have been crammed into cellars,” her husband, Victor, 65, continued.
The couple lastly determined to flee on foot on June 3. “The drones have been flying (round us) like wasps, like mosquitoes,” Galyna Zharova remembers.
They mentioned they walked for a number of kilometres earlier than they have been picked up by Ukrainian volunteers and brought to security.
‘It’s All Over’
Whereas many now refugees from Vovchansk describe dropping their houses, others speak of the neighborhood and family members who didn’t make it.
The aforementioned Nelia Stryzhakova, ran the municipal library for the previous 5 years at 8 Torhova Avenue. It went up in smoke, together with its 125,000 books after Russia attacked.
Comparability imagery reveals little else was left standing on this as soon as busy a part of city.
Much more painful for Stryzhakova, her solely son was killed preventing for Ukraine within the battle for Bakhmut.
“I now not learn Russian classics. I perceive which you could’t blame literature, however I’m disgusted with Russia, their legal guidelines, all the pieces. They took my little one away. I’m sorry, but it surely’s private,” the previous library director mentioned.
Kira Dzhafarova, who runs a personal clinic in Kharkiv, is one other to expertise the struggling of human loss. She assumes that her mom, Valentina Radionova, 85, died after refusing to go away her home within the centre of the town. Their final phone dialog was on Might 17.
She noticed her mom’s home razed to the bottom in drone footage. “Since then, I’ve realised that it’s throughout,” she says. She has given her DNA for doable identification, if and when the top of the preventing makes it doable to strategy the rubble.
Dzhafarova describes how many of the residents of Vovhchansk have been Russian audio system and had kinfolk in Russia, given the town’s proximity to the border. Some even labored throughout the border earlier than the battle, she mentioned.
Stryzhakova has the identical expertise. “There are blended households. Mother and father, youngsters – we’re all linked. And now we’ve got develop into enemies. There’s no different technique to describe it.”
The familiarity and belief, Dzhafarova believes, helped persuade her mom to remain. Propaganda can also have performed a component.
“She believed that Kharkiv could be worse than Vovchansk as a result of she watched Russian tv,” Dzhafarova mentioned.
“Horrible, Horrible Shelling”
Tamaz Gambarashvili, head of the civil and navy administration of the city neighborhood of Vovchansk, estimates that there have been round 4,000 individuals remaining when Russia’s most up-to-date offensive started.
Many of the households with youngsters had been evacuated 9 months earlier, with the town already coming beneath common Russian fireplace because the Ukrainian military recaptured it within the Autumn of 2022.
Gambarashvili, who was himself wounded when hit within the leg by a bit of shrapnel whereas directing the evacuation of the town. Others haven’t been so fortunate.
The husband of Raisa Zymovska, a kindergarten instructor, was shot lifeless whereas making an attempt to flee of their automotive. Her 83-year-old mother-in-law was additionally killed, most definitely by a Russian sniper, whereas escaping in the identical automotive, Zymovska advised AFP.
She described later being held by Russian forces for days earlier than managing to flee and conceal out within the basement of a neighbour for one evening as “horrible, horrible” shelling may very well be heard outdoors.
The subsequent day she ran for her life by a forest to security.
A deeply spiritual lady, when requested if she may forgive the Russians for killing her husband, Zymovska mentioned: “I don’t know, I simply don’t know. Properly, as a Christian, sure, however as a human – nicely, what can I say?”
Zymovska was a daily on the Myrrh Bearers church in Vovchansk. Father Igor Klymenko was the priest there. He shared photographs and movies of his congregation, in addition to footage exhibiting injury from shelling whereas he was nonetheless there.
There’s now little left of the parish with satellite tv for pc imagery exhibiting what little stays.
‘Wherever Ukraine Is, We Will Be There’
The struggle over Vovchansk is much from over. The spokesperson for the Kharkiv regional navy forces, Vitalii Sarantsev referred to as the scenario tough with Russian troops utilizing “the utmost vary of weapons” close to the town.
Russia’s MInistry of Defence didn’t reply to AFP’s request for touch upon the scenario in Vovchansk.
Nevertheless, Lieutenant Denys Yaroslavsky of Ukraine’s 57th Brigade Reconnaissance Unit advised AFP that individuals have been weary.
“I hate to say it, however loads of fighters who’ve been on the battlefield because the starting of the battle are actually drained, need to full their mission and transfer overseas. These are the troopers who are actually giving their lives for Ukraine, they usually need to transfer to different international locations,” he mentioned.
Nelia Stryzhakova has no speedy plans for her future.
“Our metropolis is gorgeous, however nobody will transfer to the border with Russia. We don’t know what is going to occur, beneath what circumstances the battle will finish and the way,” she mentioned. “However wherever Ukraine is, we will probably be there,” she added.
Jake Godin, Logan Williams, Gyula Csák, Michael Sheldon and Eoghan Macguire contributed to this report for Bellingcat.
Boris Bachorz collected interviews and reported from Kharkiv for AFP with most interviews organized because of Oleksiy Obolenskyy.
Bellingcat is a non-profit and the flexibility to hold out our work relies on the sort help of particular person donors. If you want to help our work, you are able to do so right here. You may as well subscribe to our Patreon channel right here. Subscribe to our E-newsletter and observe us on Twitter right here and Mastodon right here.
