Studying Time: 8 minutes
Wisconsin incarcerates extra individuals per capita than the vast majority of nations on the earth, together with the USA.
Wisconsin Watch and different newsrooms lately have reported on felony expenses towards employees following jail deaths, medical errors and delayed well being care and prolonged jail lockdowns linked to staffing shortages in Wisconsin prisons.
The state jail inhabitants has surged previous 23,000 individuals, with almost triple that quantity on probation or parole. In the meantime, employees vacancies are growing once more throughout the Division of Corrections.
A reader referred to as this case a “mess” and requested how we bought right here and what could be completed to repair it.
The street to mass incarceration
The primary U.S. jail was based as a “extra humane various” to public and capital punishment, jail reform advocate and ex-incarceree Baron Walker informed Wisconsin Watch. Two years after Wisconsin constructed its first jail at Waupun in 1851, the state abolished the demise penalty.
For the following century, Wisconsin’s jail inhabitants hardly ever climbed above 3,000, even because the state inhabitants grew. However as America declared the “Struggle on Medication” within the Seventies and set legal guidelines cracking down on crime within the ‘80s and ‘90s, Wisconsin’s jail inhabitants started to blow up.
“Within the early Seventies … the rise in incarceration corresponded pretty carefully with will increase in crime,” mentioned Michael O’Hear, a Marquette College felony regulation professor. “The fascinating factor that occurred in each Wisconsin and the nation as a complete within the ‘90s is that crime charges began to fall, however imprisonment charges stored going up and up.”
In accordance with O’Hear, Wisconsin was late to undertake the “tough-on-crime” legal guidelines widespread in different states throughout that period. However by the mid-Nineties, the state started to focus on drug-related crime and reverse leniency insurance policies like parole.

“There was a time period during which Milwaukee was simply transport bazillions of individuals into jail on … the presumption of being a seller with the possession of very small quantities of crack cocaine,” UW-Madison sociology Professor Emerita Pamela Oliver mentioned. She cited this observe as one of many causes Wisconsin’s racial disparities in imprisonment are the worst within the nation.
Beginning within the late Nineties and 2000s, Wisconsin’s “truth-in-sentencing” regulation, which requires individuals convicted of crimes to serve their full jail sentences with longer paroles, resulted in each a cycle of reincarceration and a big jail inhabitants filled with getting old inmates with low threat of reoffending.
Then in 2011, the anti-public union regulation often known as Act 10 induced a mass exodus of correctional officers as working situations within the state’s getting old prisons continued to deteriorate.
Prolonged supervision
Together with mandating judges impose fastened jail sentences on individuals convicted of crimes, truth-in-sentencing requires sentences to incorporate an rigid interval of “prolonged supervision” after a jail time period ends. That is completely different from parole, which is a versatile, early launch for good habits and rehabilitation.
Judges usually give out “terribly lengthy durations of prolonged supervision,” in line with Oliver, a minimum of 25% of the incarceration itself by regulation and infrequently a number of occasions that in observe. To her, it’s merely a “enormous engine in reincarceration.”
In accordance with DOC knowledge, over 60% of the 8,000 individuals admitted to Wisconsin prisons in 2024 had been in on prolonged supervision violations, often known as “revocations.” The bulk had been technical guidelines violations that didn’t contain a felony conviction.
Prolonged durations of supervision after launch from jail do little to enhance public security, analysis suggests. The lengthy phrases “might intervene with the power of these on supervision to maintain work, household life and different pro-social connections to their communities,” Cecelia Klingele, a College of Wisconsin-Madison Legislation Faculty professor of felony regulation, wrote in a 2019 research analyzing 200 revocation instances.
Substance abuse issues contributed to technical revocations in an “overwhelming majority” of instances, Klingele wrote, as a result of “brokers have few choices to impose significant sanctions apart from imprisonment.”
“Fewer, extra safety-focused situations will result in fewer pointless revocations and extra consistency in revocation for individuals whose habits poses a critical menace to public security,” Klingele added.
Streamlining the usual supervision guidelines would require the Legislature to behave.
Oliver attributes Wisconsin’s excessive charges of revocations to parole officers failing to reintegrate individuals into society in favor of taking part in “catch-somebody-offending.”
“You get reincarcerated, (and) all that point (in jail) doesn’t rely,” Oliver mentioned. “You possibly can keep on a revolving door of incarceration and prolonged supervision for 5 occasions longer than your authentic sentence.”
Individuals behind the statistics
The elements behind each crime and incarceration are complicated, with socioeconomic elements regarding poverty, race, location and extra growing the possibilities of contact with the judicial system.
In accordance with O’Hear, general crime charges started growing within the ‘90s in the course of the Struggle on Medication partially resulting from prosecutors “charging instances and plea bargaining extra aggressively.”
A research by the Equal Justice Initiative discovered that plea bargaining perpetuates racial inequality in Wisconsin prisons. White defendants are 25% extra possible than Black defendants to have expenses dropped or lowered throughout plea bargaining, and Black defendants are extra possible than whites to be convicted of their “highest preliminary cost(s).”

Within the 53206 Milwaukee ZIP code the place Baron Walker grew up, almost two-thirds of Black males are incarcerated earlier than they flip 34. Recalling his youth, Walker mentioned “it appeared like nearly all of the males in my household had been incarcerated at one cut-off date.”
Throughout his time within the jail system, which included stints at Waupun, Columbia and Fox Lake correctional establishments, Walker struggled with accessing his primary wants.
“Their water got here out black, soiled. It had a stench,” Walker mentioned. “It sinks into your clothes, even if you wash them … you devour this water, it’s what they cook dinner the meals with.”
Water high quality in Wisconsin prisons has been a constant concern of inmates and activists up to now 15 years. Regardless of a number of investigations into lead, copper and radium contamination at these maximum- and medium-security prisons, latest studies discovered unhealthy radium ranges within the consuming water — with no free options.
“They might microwave the water (at Fox Lake) and the microwaves would spark up and blow out,” WISDOM advocate Beverly Walker, Baron’s spouse, informed Wisconsin Watch. “The water on the time was $16 to only get a case of six bottles of water … it so ridiculously excessive.”
EX-incarcerated Individuals Organizing (EXPO) of Wisconsin peer help specialist Vernell Cauley’s points inside Wisconsin prisons had been extra private. His daughter died throughout his consumption into Dodge Correctional Establishment, and Cauley wasn’t allowed a brief launch to attend her funeral.
“It had some deep results on me,” he mentioned. “A number of the issues I didn’t notice I had till I used to be really launched, if you perceive that you simply didn’t get the correct time to grieve.”
Cauley was put in solitary confinement throughout that point, and for 3 months complete over the course of his jail keep. In accordance with DOC knowledge, the typical keep in solitary confinement throughout Wisconsin prisons is 2 months.
Moreover, inmates who battle with psychological sickness are overrepresented in solitary confinement throughout U.S. prisons. A number of inmates have dedicated suicide resulting from lengthy stints of solitary, significantly throughout latest jail lockdowns.
Working situations

Joe Verdegan, a former Inexperienced Bay correctional officer of almost 27 years, mentioned he and most of his coworkers “performed (them)selves fairly professionally” and “all the time had a number of respect” for inmates. This respect went each methods, he mentioned, as a result of guards constructed relationships with inmates for many years at their submit.
In accordance with Verdegan, being a correctional officer was once a “profession job” the place “no one left.” Regardless of the risks and odd work hours of the submit, the guards had a powerful union and good advantages and will climb up the ladder as they gained seniority.
But it surely “all went to hell” after Act 10 was handed.
Senior employees left in droves, leaving remaining guards with 16-hour shifts and “dangerous attitudes” that perpetuated the worsening work tradition, Verdegan mentioned. Spiritual, medical and leisure time was minimize for inmates resulting from staffing shortages, and the respect between correctional officers and prisoners dwindled.
“Whenever you’re not getting out for chapel passes or any of that form of stuff, it simply builds that hostility,” he mentioned.
The modifications induced Verdegan to retire from corrections at 51, sooner than deliberate. He and lots of of his mates took monetary penalties by retiring from the Division of Corrections early and ended up working different jobs at bars, grocery shops and factories.
In addition they went to funerals. Many former coworkers “drank themselves to demise” resulting from their experiences inside corrections, Verdegan mentioned.
Coming dwelling
In 1996, when Walker was sentenced to 60 years in jail for his position in two financial institution robberies, nobody anticipated him to serve greater than a 3rd of his sentence — not even the victims.
However when truth-in-sentencing handed, mandating judges to impose particular, rigid imprisonment lengths on individuals convicted of crimes, Walker’s hopes for an early launch shortly disintegrated.
Walker was launched from jail in 2018 on probation, an alternative choice to incarceration supplied on situation of following particular courtroom orders. He was launched after being denied parole six occasions within the seven years since he first grew to become eligible.
Within the aftermath of Walker’s imprisonment, he and Beverly have had their “most lovely days,” together with some trials. Walker mentioned he has struggled to regulate to impartial residing, and he would have been at a “full loss” for adapting to twenty years of technological change if he hadn’t studied it in jail.
“You might be programmed and reprogrammed to rely upon somebody to your something and every part, whether or not or not it’s your hygiene merchandise, the time you bathe, your mail, your mattress, your bedding, your meals,” Baron mentioned. “Now, all of the sudden, you cross out in(to) society … and also you’re informed now as an grownup you’re chargeable for your independence, your payments, your clothes, your hygiene, your every part.”
Walker has additionally struggled with discovering employment, regardless of incomes “a litany of certifications and levels” in meals service, plumbing, welding, forklift working and extra whereas incarcerated. He mentioned the DOC’s reentry packages want “overhaul” and extra firms must be inspired to rent previously incarcerated individuals.
As of 2021, Wisconsin spent $1.35 billion per yr on corrections, however solely $30 million on re-entry packages. Lower than a 3rd of the re-entry funding is allotted for serving to ex-prisoners discover jobs — though research present employment considerably decreases the probability of reoffending.
Wanting forward
To Oliver, a big barrier to fixing points inside the jail system is altering sociopolitical attitudes.
“Individuals think about that in case you’re punitive sufficient, you’ll have no crime,” Oliver mentioned. “It’s actually laborious to get most people to appreciate you finally scale back crime extra by creating the social situations that assist individuals dwell productive lives with out committing crime.”
O’Hear believes a key resolution to issues inside Wisconsin prisons is addressing the “mismatch” between giant jail populations and out there assets. He argues that “for a pair generations now, there’s been extra of a concentrate on slicing taxes than on adequately funding public companies” just like the DOC.
O’Hear additionally mentioned that judges ought to contemplate shorter jail sentences as a result of “most individuals age out of their tendency to commit crimes” and that there must be “extra sturdy mechanisms,” reminiscent of extra compassionate launch and parole legal guidelines for aged inmates.
“We have now individuals in jail of their 50s and their 60s and their 70s and even older who’re actually previous the time once they pose an actual menace to public security,” O’Hear mentioned. “Well being care prices alone for older prisoners are an incredible burden on the system, and so they’re contributing to overcrowding.”
The Walkers are persevering with their advocacy for jail reform by opening up the Integrity Heart, which helps incarcerated and previously incarcerated people with navigation, re-entry, employment help and extra. In addition they advocate completely shutting down getting old prisons reminiscent of Inexperienced Bay and Waupun correctional establishments.
“All of our people who find themselves eligible for launch must be launched, and people who find themselves eligible to maneuver into minimal services must be moved,” Beverly Walker mentioned. “We don’t want any new prisons if we simply make the most of what now we have.”
Verdegan mentioned that he doesn’t imagine the Legislature will ever move a invoice closing Inexperienced Bay in his lifetime and that “each political events are guilty for this mess they’ve created with the Wisconsin DOC.” “Throwing cash” at corrections officer positions won’t repair staffing vacancies, he mentioned, with out the assure of eight-hour workdays and sufficient job coaching.
He and Cauley each mentioned supporting the psychological well being of prisoners earlier than and after incarceration is vital. Verdegan helps coaching employees to work with mentally unwell prisoners. Cauley would reasonably see jail abolished altogether.
“Most individuals who find yourself in prisons, they’ve issues occurring mentally, these points not getting met,” Cauley mentioned. “Jail solely makes individuals bitter, extra offended … you realize, it traumatizes them.”