Half of Wisconsin college districts go to referendum

Studying Time: 4 minutes

Come Nov. 5, practically half of all Wisconsin college districts can have gone to referendum in 2024, asking for nearly $6 billion in whole from Wisconsin residents in districts scattered throughout the state.

At the very least 192 college districts — of the state’s 421 — can have posed 241 referendum inquiries to residents of their districts this 12 months, in line with knowledge from the state Division of Public Instruction. That features seven college districts that posed 10 questions in February, 86 districts that posed 93 questions in April, one district that posed one query in August, and a minimum of 121 college districts that may pose some 137 inquiries to voters in November. (Some college districts ask voters to think about multiple referendum query on the identical poll.) 

The push from districts for added funding comes as the talk over state help for Okay-12 public faculties has change into central to many aggressive legislative races. Lawmakers elevated funding for public faculties by $1 billion in the course of the state’s most up-to-date price range cycle, although that improve was tied to extra funding for public constitution and personal voucher faculties. Gov. Tony Evers and legislative Democrats are prone to as soon as once more push for added funding throughout price range negotiations subsequent summer time.

Federal pandemic aid funds that Wisconsin college districts have been in a position to spend since 2020 will expire this month. 

Voters accredited 62 of the 103 college referendums on the first and basic election ballots this spring — a report quantity since a minimum of 2000. The 60% approval fee was the bottom in a midterm or presidential election 12 months since 2010, in line with the Wisconsin Coverage Discussion board. 

Why are faculties pushing to referendum?

As districts throughout the state grapple with declining enrollment, many are pressured to shut and consolidate faculties of their district to chop again on prices, significantly working bills. The Kenosha Unified College District closed six of its faculties this 12 months as a consequence of declining enrollment after going through a $15 million deficit.

“Colleges are funded primarily based on the variety of college students we’ve, in order we’ve fewer college students, our price range shrinks,” Kenosha Superintendent Jeffrey Weiss instructed Wisconsin Watch. 

Wisconsin’s per-pupil Okay-12 spending has elevated at a decrease fee than each different state within the nation moreover Indiana and Idaho between 2002 and 2020, in line with the Coverage Discussion board.

Enrollment losses create situations the place prices exceed the per-pupil income out there to the district. State regulation permits college districts to then go to referendum to ask their voters to authorize their district to exceed their income caps on the expense of property taxpayers. 

In 2009, the state Legislature decoupled per-pupil income limits from inflation. With out matching inflation, college districts have been slashing their budgets for years. 

“Maintaining the income restrict up with inflation might be the largest want that the district has,” Weiss mentioned. “For 2025-26, we’re taking a look at one other important deficit.” 

The La Crosse College District’s November referendum is asking for $53.5 million to construct a brand new elementary college and add new school rooms to a different. The district would subsequently shut a number of elementary faculties and relocate college students.

“Frankly, when you might have fewer youngsters you want fewer buildings,” Superintendent Aaron Engel mentioned. “Altering income limits isn’t going to alter the necessity for college districts throughout the state, in the event that they’re bigger like ours, to shut buildings and consolidate.”

Engel mentioned tying the income limits to inflation was a terrific mannequin, and the hole between inflationary will increase and what they’re offered is now over $3,000 per pupil. That represents $18 million in misplaced income during the last 16 years. This considerably impacts the district’s means to function its faculties, he mentioned.

Election Day is Nov. 5. Get all the data you could vote.

Declining enrollment

There are a number of components contributing to declining enrollment in faculties, one of many largest being declining delivery charges. However housing shortages in some districts like La Crosse have additionally made issues worse.

A lot of the housing being in-built La Crosse is multifamily or medium-density housing, in line with Engel. The district has discovered that multifamily housing generates far fewer school-aged youngsters than single-family housing.

“There isn’t actually house for brand new housing or single-family houses,” Engel mentioned. “With declining delivery charges and folks having fewer youngsters of their households — naturally, with the identical stage of housing — our enrollment has declined.”

Non-public college vouchers and open enrollment have additionally contributed to declining enrollment, Engel mentioned. The usage of open enrollment in Wisconsin has elevated over the final decade.

How will candidates for workplace deal with it? 

Seven-term Rep. Steve Doyle — a Democrat looking for reelection within the La Crosse space — mentioned that having to push to referendum “is the worst technique to do it” and that funding public faculties shouldn’t be left as much as the property taxpayers. 

“It’s actually type of a stab within the again after we’re having to approve a referendum that we all know must be handed, however it actually is masking one thing that the state needs to be masking,” Doyle mentioned. 

Final 12 months Doyle co-authored a invoice that may have allowed public faculties with failed referendums to profit from the state’s elevated income limits.

However Rep. Tom Michalski — a Republican from Elm Grove looking for a second time period — mentioned the difficulty in Wauwatosa’s college district isn’t funding, and “the billion {dollars} that we’re giving out … demonstrates that.”

The Wauwatosa College District will go to each capital and operational referendum this November, totaling $124.4 million. The district is anticipated to face a $9.3 million deficit this college 12 months.

“I don’t suppose elevating taxes is ever in style, however the residents of Wauwatosa must query what they’re getting for his or her cash,” Michalski mentioned of referendums within the district. “If the varsity has dropped in its efficiency over the previous years, they need to actually take a look at the place the cash goes.”

Because the college district is “on the decline,” mother and father have each proper to ship their youngsters to a personal college, Michalski mentioned. If Wauwatosa faculties can’t compete, “that’s their downside.” 

Final 12 months, Michalski co-sponsored laws handed as a part of a compromise between Republicans and Evers that raised income ceilings for public faculties and elevated tax funding for personal voucher faculties on the similar time.

Jack Kelly contributed reporting to this story.

Ahead is a glance forward on the week in Wisconsin authorities and politics from the Wisconsin Watch statehouse crew.