Lessie Ann Patterson lived in Monticello, Illinois, for 25 years earlier than dying in 2015 from glioblastoma, a quickly advancing mind most cancers with a median survival time of 12 to 18 months.
Belinda Barnhart, Patterson’s stepdaughter, witnessed firsthand the results of glioblastoma in her household.
“There was no clear motive why she ended up with it,” Barnhart stated in an interview. “After which whenever you hear about so a lot of them within the Monticello space, you simply take into consideration all of the devastation it has brought about, and it does make you need to say, ‘Why is that this one space so rife with glioblastoma particularly?’”
Patterson was considered one of many victims of mind most cancers in Piatt County which have been recognized by a neighborhood researcher and well being skilled, Caitlin McClain.
Issues in regards to the variety of circumstances got here to mild final 12 months when McClain began researching and gathering data on glioblastoma circumstances in Monticello and Piatt County following the demise of her father-in-law from the illness in 2022.
As of final fall, she stated she had collected data on not less than 30 circumstances from the previous 20 years — with not less than 14 deaths from the most cancers in simply the final 5 years. McClain collected her information via obituaries, surveys and talking with residents.
She stated she has needed to examine on her personal as a result of public well being information lags years behind and typically is suppressed — that’s, not disclosed — for smaller counties that will permit people to be recognized. Piatt County’s inhabitants is about 16,700, of which simply over 6,000 folks dwell in Monticello, in accordance the most recent census information.
McClain took her findings to the Illinois Division of Public Well being a number of occasions in 2024, however she stated division officers didn’t comply with the federal well being pointers for investigating attainable most cancers clusters and dismissed her considerations, saying the numbers didn’t point out a most cancers cluster.
However there’s a protocol from the Facilities for Illness Management and Prevention (CDC) and the American Most cancers Society, on how an company ought to reply. The CDC has pointers for responding to reviews of suspicious numbers of most cancers circumstances and requires public well being businesses to speak to residents and go to the group.
Glioblastoma has an incidence price of about 3.2 circumstances per 100,000 folks in keeping with a 2017 examine accessible on the Nationwide Library of Medication. For Piatt County, the speed of mind most cancers, which incorporates glioblastoma, from 2017 to 2021 was 9.1 for males on common. The registry counted 5 male circumstances throughout that point. It was solely a 1.2 price for females and the registry reported one case.
But McClain’s information reveals 5 girls dwelling in or primarily from Monticello died of glioblastoma between 2017 and 2021 together with Tina M. Purcell, a resident of Monticello since she married in 1990, and lifelong resident Connie Jean Hendrix.
“I’ve spoken to so many individuals at this level it’s troublesome to maintain observe of all the pieces,” McClain stated in October.
Citing McClain’s information and knowledge, Barnhart, whose stepmother died, stated the state division’s response has been disappointing.
“It’s extremely disappointing that your native public well being workplace received’t even entertain the concept one thing may very well be happening particularly in that space, that there may very well be a most cancers cluster,” she stated.
After quite a few calls from CU-CitizenAccess, Michael Claffey, the general public well being division spokesperson, responded in December 2024.
“I’ll attempt to discover out extra about this,” Claffey wrote in an e-mail.
However with federal funding for public well being underneath siege, Claffey stated in February:
“Sorry for the gradual response to this. We have now actually been swamped not too long ago given all of the federal adjustments and all the pieces else that is occurring. I don’t have something for you at this level.”
McClain stated Chief Medical Officer Arti Barnes on the state public well being division requested for an replace from her in early February this 12 months, however “there was zero communication from IDPH in any other case.”
College researchers stated circumstances are regarding
Biomedical researchers on the College of Illinois Urbana-Champaign stated they’re involved in regards to the reviews of glioblastoma in Monticello.
Professor Catherine Alicia Greatest-Popescu, a biomedical researcher on the College of Illinois whose focus is molecular, mobile and tissue engineering, stated in December that Monticello’s glioblastoma charges are value investigating, calling the sample a “large cluster.” Glioblastoma, she defined, is notoriously difficult to deal with resulting from its aggressive nature.
“It’s a extremely not possible most cancers to deal with as a result of it might probably evade your immune system, evade radiation remedy,” Popescu stated. “We give it a superpower in a means.”
The CDC units clear pointers for investigating most cancers clusters, which prioritize circumstances with higher-than-expected numbers of uncommon cancers like glioblastoma. The investigations require consultants to check the most cancers information to ascertain if there’s a regarding price.
Underneath these pointers, well being departments’ companions and officers are anticipated to evaluate information from most cancers registries and different databases to watch the estimated charges of most cancers incidents routinely. The rules notice that state sources and small populations can prohibit state well being departments from proactively reviewing or monitoring most cancers information.
The CDC additionally stated a most cancers cluster will need to have considered one of these traits:
- There’s a greater-than-expected variety of a particular kind of most cancers (or forms of most cancers which can be recognized to have a standard trigger).
- There are a number of circumstances of a uncommon kind of most cancers.
- The cancers are a sort that isn’t often seen in a sure group of individuals (for instance, youngsters getting most cancers often seen in adults).
For rural Illinois residents, accessing details about the incidence of most cancers of their space is troublesome as a result of most cancers information are typically suppressed in rural areas resulting from considerations of confidentiality and small populations.
Suppressed means the variety of circumstances don’t present up on state maps and information.
Whereas the purpose of the U.S. Census Bureau’s privateness safety system is to guard particular person identities by injecting statistical noise into mixture inhabitants information, a examine by the Nationwide Library of Medication discovered discrepancies enhance dramatically in rural areas, elevating considerations that the brand new system might misrepresent inhabitants tendencies and demographic adjustments.
“Every time we discuss it, they are saying, ‘Strive to not be alarmed.’ We’re very alarmed. We’re very upset about it. It’s completely unacceptable.” Popescu stated.
Severity of circumstances questioned by public well being
Final 12 months, McClain stated a number of state officers questioned whether or not her information signifies a most cancers cluster, together with these from the Illinois Most cancers Registry, the state public well being division and state representatives.
The Illinois Division of Public Well being — tasked with defending public well being and the surroundings — stated the variety of circumstances was not alarming and there was no want or sources to look into the circumstances. Officers stated McClain’s information didn’t point out proof of a most cancers cluster as a result of the speed of the circumstances was inadequate.
When McClain first contacted well being officers in early 2024 she had documented 19 circumstances of glioblastoma since 2004. By October, she recognized 30 circumstances whole since 2004 — with seven circumstances inside 2.3 sq. miles in Monticello.
Underneath most cancers cluster investigation pointers, the Illinois Division of Public Well being is anticipated to evaluate information accessible from most cancers registries and different databases to watch the estimated charges for most cancers incidents.
However databases and most cancers registries are outdated. In keeping with the CDC, the most recent most cancers incidence information accessible are from 2021, 4 years in the past, and up to date most cancers demise information are from 2022. Illinois’s most cancers incidence information is from 2021.
McClain stated she discovered not less than 11 folks with glioblastoma died between 2017 and 2021, of which 6 have been males and 5 have been girls.
In response to a Freedom of Info Act (FOIA) request to the state public well being division in November, a FOIA officer stated “the Division follows CDC pointers when figuring out whether or not and learn how to examine or assess a most cancers cluster.”
As of February this 12 months, no extra investigation by the Illinois Division of Public Well being had been completed.
Reason for glioblastoma unclear, linked to pesticides
Whereas glioblastoma’s precise causes stay unclear, publicity to carcinogens, radiation and agricultural chemical substances has been linked to DNA mutations that drive the illness.
Nationwide research present that insecticides, that are extensively used within the county and within the Midwest, have been linked to mind most cancers. This relationship may be seen in research from the Nationwide Library of Medication “Mind tumours and publicity to pesticides” and “Organochlorine Pesticides and Epigenetic Alterations in Mind Most cancers.”
“It’s my opinion that Illinois as a complete refuses to just accept that agricultural chemical substances pose threat to human life,” McClain stated in October. “They appear to be behind in analysis and correspondence with the general public in comparison with different rural states … Some farmers have left more room between their crops and the houses and colleges this 12 months as soon as I introduced the danger to their consideration.”
In response to McClain asking for the town of Monticello to check the water, officers did so and noticed nothing worrisome within the outcomes, which confirmed no violations for disinfectants or inorganic contaminants.
Water check reviews from 2023, obtained in an e-mail from Monticello Public Works, present most regulated contaminants are inside acceptable ranges.
“Any time Caitlin has introduced one thing to our consideration, we’ve expeditiously regarded into it and gone from there,” Monticello Metropolis Administrator Terry Summers stated in an interview in November 2024.
Summers initiated water exams of the county’s water provide and located the nitrate ranges have been nearly undetectable. He stated there was no signal that the general public water provide was behind the variety of mind cancers.
In keeping with the American Most cancers Society, greater than 1,000 suspected most cancers clusters are reported to state well being departments in the US annually.
The stakes are excessive for these recognized with glioblastoma: the typical survival time is simply 12 to 18 months, even with aggressive therapy.
Gita Kwatra, CEO of the Glioblastoma Basis Inc, a non-profit group in Durham, North Carolina, stated glioblastoma is the commonest malignant mind tumor, with slim survival charges.
“The illness is extremely quick, extremely deadly most cancers. There isn’t sufficient analysis funding that goes to this most cancers. There isn’t sufficient consciousness,” Kwatra stated in a telephone interview. “5 to seven % of people who find themselves recognized will survive to 5 years, and 5 years is necessary within the medical group, 5 years is used as a surrogate marker for beating the illness.”
Republish our articles without cost, on-line or in print.
