Right here’s the place Donald Trump, Kamala Harris have stood

Studying Time: 6 minutes

A household stood exterior the doorways of St. Francis Group Free Clinic at 4:55 p.m. on a latest Monday, 5 minutes earlier than it was set to open. 

A volunteer receptionist switched on the Oshkosh, Wisconsin, clinic’s “open” signal and welcomed them inside. Inside minutes, extra sufferers filed into the ready room. Volunteers referred to as folks again to see Dr. Weston Radford on a first-come, first-served foundation.

The clinic technically closes at 7 p.m. on Mondays, however Radford, who volunteers right here weekly, mentioned he typically stays to deal with sufferers previous 8 p.m. — 14 hours after beginning his workday as an inside drugs physician at a personal clinic close by. 

Nonetheless the free clinic in its restricted hours can’t attain everybody who wants it, together with many who lack ample medical insurance.   

“Well being care remains to be a giant want that we’re not likely filling,” Radford mentioned. 

Well being care is on the minds of loads of Wisconsin residents forward of the November election. 

Greater than two dozen individuals who responded to WPR’s America Amplified challenge mentioned they need politicians to prioritize well being care entry. Eight referred to as for increasing entry to Medicaid, the joint state and federal assist program to assist low-income residents afford care.

Wisconsin is dwelling to greater than 1.2 million Medicaid recipients and an estimated 310,000 individuals who lack insurance coverage.  

Voters weighing their choices for president have heard little from former President Donald Trump, a Republican, or Vice President Kamala Harris, a Democrat, about Medicaid coverage. Nonetheless, their previous information and get together affiliations paint drastically totally different prospects for this system after November, in response to the well being coverage analysis agency KFF.

“Medicaid and its future, whether or not it faces existential threats, will rely upon the end result of this fall’s federal election,” mentioned Edwin Park, a public coverage professor at Georgetown College.

Trump beforehand pushed Medicaid cuts 

Residents may lose Medicaid entry, specialists say, if Trump as president efficiently revives his previous proposals to shrink the dimensions of this system — leaving extra low-income adults reliant on busy clinics like St. Francis.

Undertaking 2025, a plan for a second Trump administration revealed by the far-right Heritage Basis, together with chapters written by former Trump administration officers, proposes main cuts to federal Medicaid spending and toughened eligibility necessities. 

These proposals align with Trump’s monitor file. His administration elevated scrutiny over eligibility for recipients, allowed states so as to add work necessities and proposed trimming round $1 trillion over 10 years from the federal Medicaid funds — cuts that Congress didn’t go in 2017.

Nonetheless, Trump has tried to distance himself from Undertaking 2025.    

“Solely President Trump and the marketing campaign, and NOT another group or former workers, characterize insurance policies for the second time period,” Danielle Alvarez, a senior adviser for Trump’s marketing campaign, wrote in a press release to WPR and Wisconsin Watch.

The marketing campaign didn’t reply to questions on whether or not Trump helps Undertaking 2025 proposals to restrict state Medicaid funding via block grants and impose lifetime limits on advantages. 

“President Donald J. Trump is unwavering in his mission to decrease prices for seniors and defend Social Safety, Medicare, and Medicaid,” Jacob Fischer, a Wisconsin spokesperson for Trump’s marketing campaign, instructed WPR and Wisconsin Watch.

A 16-page Trump coverage plan guarantees protections for Medicare, the federal government well being protection for seniors and adults with disabilities, however by no means mentions Medicaid.

Harris touts excessive Medicaid enrollment with few specifics

In the meantime, an 82-page Harris marketing campaign doc touts record-high protection ranges throughout her administration with President Joe Biden, however it doesn’t articulate particular Medicaid insurance policies. 

A Harris marketing campaign spokesperson didn’t straight reply when requested about particular Medicaid proposals.   

“Donald Trump is campaigning on a promise to repeal the Inexpensive Care Act and would spike prices underneath his excessive Undertaking 2025 agenda, a stark distinction from Vice President Kamala Harris’ plan to tackle Massive Pharma and produce down well being care prices for households throughout Wisconsin,” Brianna Johnson, the marketing campaign’s Wisconsin spokesperson, responded by way of e-mail.

Harris pushed a extra dramatic well being care overhaul in 2019 whereas operating within the Democratic presidential main. She cosponsored the failed “Medicare for All” invoice, which might have granted Individuals common protection to exchange private-pay insurance coverage and Medicaid. 

Harris has since sought to distance herself from Medicare for All. Trump has attacked Harris for having “flip flopped” on what his marketing campaign calls a “socialist” proposal, and he has unfold deceptive claims about what it will have meant for immigrants who entered the nation illegally. 

Harris doesn’t point out Medicare for All in her present platform. She as a substitute describes plans to bolster Medicare and the Inexpensive Care Act, generally referred to as “Obamacare” — a legislation Trump has repeatedly pushed to repeal. 

What does Medicaid coverage imply for Wisconsin?

Wisconsin has a smaller proportion of uninsured residents than most states, however it stays amongst simply 10 that haven’t expanded Medicaid to cowl adults under 138% of the federal poverty line, round $20,800 a yr for a single grownup. 

Adopting enlargement would enable Wisconsin to increase authorities protection to as much as 90,900 extra adults and reap a internet good thing about $1.7 billion over two years, in response to a Wisconsin Coverage Discussion board estimate. 

Trump’s Inexpensive Care Act repeal efforts would have ended Medicaid enlargement nationwide. The federal authorities can’t power states to develop protection, however Congress through the Biden-Harris administration authorized monetary incentives to encourage enlargement.

Wisconsin’s Republican-led Legislature rejected the latest enlargement proposal. Legislators have argued it will trigger extra residents to overly depend on the federal government, improve non-public insurance coverage prices and burden future taxpayers.

Republican enlargement critics level out that of the states that haven’t expanded Medicaid, Wisconsin is the one one with out what some name a protection hole. 

That’s as a result of the state’s Medicaid program covers low-income adults making as much as the federal poverty degree — the identical level at which they qualify for backed plans on the federal Well being Insurance coverage Market.

However Medicaid is seen as extra complete protection than Market choices. Wisconsin’s Medicaid program covers dental care. However a Market enrollee could have to pay an additional premium for dental protection.

Two-thirds of respondents in a KFF ballot of non-expansion states, together with Wisconsin, mentioned they favored enlargement.

Whereas voters in six Republican-led states authorized Medicaid enlargement via poll initiatives since 2020, Wisconsin voters lack the flexibility to place referendums on the poll.

Some specialists see Wisconsin’s new electoral maps as a possible path for enlargement.

That is the primary election after the Wisconsin Supreme Court docket ordered lawmakers to attract new state Meeting and Senate district boundaries. The brand new maps create the potential for Democrats gaining a majority within the state Meeting on account of extra aggressive districts. 

Whereas a Democrat-led Senate stays unlikely, management over one chamber may nonetheless transfer enlargement debates ahead, mentioned Philip Rocco, an affiliate professor of political science at Marquette College.

“Even when there’s not a victory instantly, it would create some political momentum for one to occur finally,” Rocco mentioned.

Radford isn’t positive why Wisconsin hasn’t expanded Medicaid, however he stays hopeful.

It could ease a few of his work at his day job on the non-public clinic. Having extra folks on Medicare or Medicaid may lower worries about denials or massive out-of-pocket prices.

“It’d be good simply to have the ability to deal with the folks what we expect medically is the most effective for them,” Radford mentioned.

Even underneath enlargement, loads of Wisconsin residents will nonetheless want to go to free clinics like St. Francis. 

‘We simply deal with them’ 

Every week Radford sees sufferers who lack ample non-public insurance coverage, are in between protection or can’t qualify for Medicaid due to their citizenship standing.

Such wants aren’t new. Radford’s dad volunteered at St. Francis for round 30 years, spanning a number of  presidential administrations.

Whereas well being care insurance policies have modified over time, the clinic’s mission hasn’t. Nobody on the entrance desk asks questions on insurance coverage or different varieties of cost. Nobody will get turned away.

“Individuals bought to be seen,” Radford mentioned. “So we simply deal with them.”

Wisconsin Watch is a nonprofit, nonpartisan newsroom. Subscribe to our newsletters for authentic tales and our Friday information roundup.