Assessment of Wisconsin discuss radio finds stark divides, misinformation

Studying Time: 9 minutes

The 2024 Tremendous Bowl was a Sunday afternoon of American unity round good meals, household and mates, humorous adverts, the halftime present and, after all, soccer. The following morning, the variations in dialogue amongst numerous Wisconsin radio hosts throughout the political spectrum couldn’t have been starker.

Conservative discuss present host Dan O’Donnell on WISN in Milwaukee shortly shifted from discussing his lifetime assist for the Kansas Metropolis Chiefs to sarcastically suggesting President Joe Biden didn’t sit for a pre-game interview on account of his poor psychological acuity.

Pat Kreitlow, a former Democratic lawmaker turned liberal discuss present host of UpNorthNews Radio on Civic Media, interviewed frequent present visitor Kristin Lyerly — who would quickly after be launching a congressional marketing campaign — about her involvement within the 1992 Tremendous Bowl halftime present.

One other conservative discuss present host, Vicki McKenna on WIBA in Madison and WISN, derided a efficiency of “Carry Each Voice and Sing,” also referred to as the “Black nationwide anthem,” being sung earlier than the U.S. nationwide anthem as a “pretend nationwide anthem.”

Milwaukee WNOV host Michelle Bryant, a politically energetic Democrat, associated the quantity of taxpayer cash used to construct the brand new Las Vegas Raiders stadium to an area housing difficulty.

Additionally in Milwaukee, WTMJ’s Steve Scaffidi, a self-described Republican, spent a phase on his present discussing with a co-host and callers which Tremendous Bowl adverts had been their favorites.

WPR’s Rob Ferrett didn’t point out the Tremendous Bowl on the high of his since-canceled afternoon present “Central Time,” as an alternative doing interviews with Sen. Tammy Baldwin about environmental points alongside the Mississippi River, the writer of a ebook on how fashionable drugs has been biased in opposition to ladies and a Wisconsin movie knowledgeable on the historical past of a 100-year-old pipe organ in a Milwaukee theater.

Divided Individuals are sometimes described as residing in several media bubbles, so for this story College of Wisconsin-Madison journalism college students listened to a number of radio hosts throughout the political spectrum to report on simply how totally different these bubbles are.

They listened to 6 hosts specifically for 4 hours every through the week of Feb. 12 and continued to hearken to these hosts and take notes all through the remainder of the semester on what they heard. For these 4 hours they checked each assertion from every host for any factual errors. The scholars categorized any opinions they heard as liberal, average or conservative.

The scholars discovered clear variations in how a lot every host opined, how a lot they requested questions of visitor consultants, how typically they spoke with callers and the way a lot promoting appeared on every program.

However maybe essentially the most notable discovering was that stations with the most important viewers and essentially the most promoting gave a platform to the hosts who offered essentially the most misinformation.

Misinformation

The investigation discovered McKenna made 39 unsupported or provably false statements over the course of the 4 hours reviewed, adopted by O’Donnell’s 14. Kreitlow and Bryant every had three, Scaffidi had two and Ferrett — the one one of many six whose present has since been canceled — had zero.

McKenna, a longtime conservative firebrand, had her information mistaken on immigration, Wisconsin politics and claims that the 2020 election was rigged. Considered one of her predominant targets was Wisconsin Elections Fee Administrator Meagan Wolfe, whom McKenna blamed for selections made by the six-member bipartisan Wisconsin Elections Fee.

“Wisconsin ought to have been received for (President Donald) Trump however for Meagan Wolfe,” McKenna stated, referencing a disputed examine from conservative suppose tank The Heartland Institute.

She additionally unfold false claims that the shooter at Joel Osteen’s megachurch who wounded two folks was a transgender immigrant within the nation illegally. In actuality, the shooter had lived in Texas for some years with a state ID and didn’t establish as transgender.

“The shooter is a person who’s an unlawful migrant from El Salvador who identifies as a girl,” McKenna stated. “So what number of does that make now? Eight? Seven? Trans shooters?”

A 2023 reality test of the declare of an increase in transgender shooters additionally discovered no proof to assist it. On the time, solely 0.1% of mass shootings since 2016 had been carried out by somebody who recognized as transgender, far fewer than than 1.6% of Individuals who establish as transgender or nonbinary.

McKenna declined an interview request and didn’t reply to a number of emails in search of her evaluate of the statements flagged by college students. A Wisconsin Watch evaluate of greater than 50 statements flagged by college students whittled the checklist all the way down to 39 that weren’t supported by proof or could possibly be disproven with credible sourcing.

O’Donnell’s misstatements included claims that Huge Macs had shrunk over the earlier decade (they haven’t), {that a} Tremendous Bowl advert that includes totally different folks washing ft used AI-generated photos (it didn’t) and that Walgreens shops had been closing due to rampant theft (the corporate stated these claims had been overblown a 12 months earlier).

When offered with an inventory of greater than 20 statements the scholars had flagged, O’Donnell threatened to write down an article about how Wisconsin Watch was “utilizing” College of Wisconsin college students. Wisconsin Watch has partnered on tasks with UW-Madison’s investigative journalism class for years as a part of its dedication to coach present and future investigative journalists.

O’Donnell additionally stated he would title in his article the scholar who interviewed him for this collection and claimed the scholar didn’t inform him the interview was for Wisconsin Watch. In reality, the scholar had knowledgeable O’Donnell that the story was for Wisconsin Watch by e-mail earlier than interviewing him.

“That is about as underhanded because it will get and I imagine his potential employers ought to learn about his (and your) utter lack of primary journalistic ideas,” O’Donnell wrote. He didn’t supply any response concerning the flagged claims. The Wisconsin Watch evaluate whittled the checklist to 14.

In distinction, when Bryant was offered with 5 flagged statements, she supplied proof to assist two of them (Wisconsin Watch subsequently agreed they weren’t misstatements) and acknowledged she misspoke on the opposite three.

“I imagine it is very important have correct data and am joyful to reply to the questions that you’ve got posed,” Bryant responded. “I’ll misspeak, however not deliberately or lie or give misinformation. That grates me.”

Ferrett, who moved to a shorter morning present slot after his afternoon drive-time present was canceled, structured his present round dwell interviews with visitors. He made no false statements, one thing that will have been simpler given the vast majority of occasions he spoke on his present he wasn’t expressing an opinion or making a press release — he was asking a query.

The discuss radio scene in Wisconsin has modified in some ways, together with in regard to misinformation, in response to former WTMJ host Charlie Sykes. Throughout his greater than 25 years on the air, he could be referred to as out if he received one thing mistaken. Listeners nonetheless tended to get their data from either side by conventional media sources.

“For lots of those guys now there is no such thing as a reality test. There isn’t any draw back. There isn’t any place that they go, ‘Oh my gosh. I’m gonna get busted for this,’” Sykes stated in an interview. “That is the way it’s totally different from the olden occasions once I was on the radio, as a result of if I received one thing mistaken, the native newspaper would slap me and they’d slap me onerous.”

Sykes attributed the rise in misinformation on conservative discuss radio to a cycle of elevated demand from audiences for partisan catering and outrage.

“The analogy that works for me the most effective is people who find themselves promoting meth on the road nook and someone else comes on and so they promote a stronger type of meth. And you retain having to must compete with that,” Sykes stated. “It’s not simply leisure, it’s maintaining with the viewers’s demand to continually be fed what they’re searching for.”

Extra promoting on conservative stations

This summer time WISN host Mark Belling introduced the station has the most important viewers share of any discuss radio station within the nation. That’s obvious from the numerous quantity of economic promoting on the station.

O’Donnell’s present persistently featured 15-20 minutes of promoting, or roughly 30% of every hour of airtime. Advertisers hawked a variety of services together with actual property, dwelling reworking and restore, divorce attorneys, monetary advisers, grocery shops and auto restore. One firm, MyPatriotSupply.com, took on the fear-mongering tone of a right-wing discuss present host in its advert.

“It’s simple to see we’re being conned by the establishments we used to belief,” the advert started. “The mainstream media is distracting us with meaningless headlines as an alternative of specializing in the tough realities going through American households. Everyone knows one thing large is coming. And that’s why so many people are making ready. They’re turning into extra self-reliant by investing in emergency meals storage from My Patriot Provide.”

Kreitlow’s present on Civic Media persistently featured 5-10 minutes of promoting, or roughly 10% of every hour of airtime.

The ads on UpNorthNews Radio had been primarily for various reveals from proprietor Civic Media. The present often had ads for an auto elements retailer, in addition to from A Higher Wisconsin Collectively, a progressive group that enhances Democrats.

Ads throughout McKenna’s present, which seems on WIBA in Madison and WISN in Milwaukee, each iHeartMedia stations, had been largely non-political, however people who had been political included adverts from the Democratic Legislative Marketing campaign Committee, a corporation that, in response to its web site, seeks to place Democrats in workplace throughout the nation. 

Adverts airing throughout McKenna’s and O’Donnell’s reveals inspired listeners to purchase gold shares by gold IRAs.

On “Central Time,” which featured sponsors such because the Wisconsin Division of Tourism and a nature pastime retailer in Madison, Ferrett and visitor Jeremy Merrill from the Washington Put up mentioned how the kind of gold IRAs marketed on conservative shops has turn into the topic of lawsuits.

Firms working gold IRAs typically take giant commissions or premiums that go away traders with much less cash than they began with, even when gold shares went up, Merrill stated. These gold funding firms have been taken to court docket a number of occasions, however have efficiently argued that their processes are clear, leaving traders at a loss.

Worldviews differ throughout stations 

The six hosts represented a variety of political viewpoints throughout the political spectrum, with Bryant and Kreitlow voicing virtually fully liberal opinions, O’Donnell and McKenna voicing virtually fully conservative opinions and Scaffidi expressing predominantly average factors of view.

Not all political dialogue tilted by some means. Ferrett largely interviewed consultants and kept away from including his opinions — as an alternative offering the most recent information on Trump’s felony court docket proceedings or Biden’s actions in workplace.

O’Donnell and McKenna clearly displayed their views about Trump and Biden. O’Donnell described himself in an interview as an opinion journalist who prosecutes the case in opposition to liberalism and the Democratic Social gathering on his present. He not often talked about Trump and continually needled Biden, oftentimes sarcastically.

“Do you bear in mind President Biden’s press convention?” O’Donnell stated throughout his Feb. 15 present. “He doesn’t, however I’m positive you do.”

McKenna steadily demonized Biden and praised Trump utilizing hyperbolic, incendiary language.

“Joe Biden desires you to suppose he’s the nice man … however would the nice guys facilitate human intercourse trafficking of youngsters?” McKenna requested whereas discussing immigration.

Bryant, who typically talks about native politics, talked about how Trump throughout his presidency issued an government order to cease all range, fairness and inclusion coaching from federal companies.

“Once you received Black males sitting up (and) speaking about, ‘I’m voting for Trump,’ and I’m like, do you perceive that this man doesn’t worth your contributions?” Bryant stated.

She made her distaste for Trump clear with out mentioning Biden as soon as through the 4 hours reviewed.

Kreitlow contrasted Trump’s and Biden’s data, describing how steadily they’d visited Wisconsin and the way they dealt with categorized paperwork.

“There may be such a distinction between how President Biden dealt with paperwork, particularly as vice chairman, in comparison with a president-turned-former president (Trump) and all of the paperwork and nationwide secrets and techniques and the sloppy means they had been saved at Mar-a-Lago,” Kreitlow stated. 

In bolstering Biden, Kreitlow instructed his viewers about Trump’s authorized troubles, just like how O’Donnell attacked Biden’s reminiscence in protection of Trump.

Scaffidi describes himself as a Republican however typically expressed anti-Trump opinions, questioning Trump’s Republican credentials. He disagreed with lots of Trump’s insurance policies and decisions, citing variations between his actions and his phrases.

“It’s considerably fascinating that he’s thought of a conservative by some folks,” Scaffidi stated. “I might argue he’s probably not even a Republican but right here he’s, the principal nominee for the nomination for president. I don’t know if I can reconcile all of that.”

Scaffidi additionally criticized the dominance of conservative discuss radio in southeastern Wisconsin, which his predecessor at WTMJ, Sykes, helped pioneer.

“This market, specifically Milwaukee, in southeastern Wisconsin, it has been contaminated by — and I do know folks made some huge cash doing it — fixed noise, fixed screaming right into a microphone by primarily outdated white males, about politics in essentially the most twisted vogue, which has, frankly, polluted our minds on these things,” Scaffidi instructed his viewers. “Listening to a few hours or two hours or no matter, of somebody simply saying issues they agree with. How is that attention-grabbing? What sort of world can we dwell in, the place everybody agrees with you on a regular basis? Appears foolish, specious, dumb, uninformed, intellectually lazy. However right here we’re.”

Republish This Story

Republish our articles without spending a dime, on-line or in print, underneath a Artistic Commons license.